John Gscheidmeier Real Estate Agent at RE/MAX Service First, LLC

John Gscheidmeier

Real Estate Agent at
RE/MAX Service First, LLC

Currently accepting new clients

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins
  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Investment Properties
  • Relocations
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • New Construction
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Experienced Home Buyers & Sellers

Is John the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well John's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

John is a SFH expert - working with over 74% more single family homes than the average Milwaukee agent.
John has great Condo experience - having sold 26 more condos than the average agent.

More about John Gscheidmeier

I am the broker/owner of RE/MAX Service First, LLC, based in Waukesha, WI. I am an expert in real estate negotiations, locations, and I specialize in residential home buying and selling. Having been in real estate for over 22 years, I have bought, sold, managed and brokered real estate transactions helping my clients find the home of their dreams, as well as sell their current home. Customer service is paramount and having non-stop open lines of communication is crucial to the buying and selling process. Clients of mine are treated with respect and are part of our team and the team at Service First Pros. We make decisions together putting your interests and desires first. It is my job to anticipate possible issues affecting your transaction, as well as professionally work through those that often times occur. Home buying should be a fun process, and I enjoy getting to know my clients and making this a fun process.

Cardinal Stritch University, University of Wisconsin-Whitewater, Waukesha Catholic Memorial


ABR, BPOR, PSA, Pricing Strategy Advisor Certification (PSA)


Five Star Professional Agent 2015-2018, Five Star Professional Agent 2019

License Number


John Gscheidmeier's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
John Gscheidmeier

    • John and his team have done 16 transactions with us. This includes both purchasing and selling of the the properties. John and his team are always professional and knowledgeable. Jeff Steier

      - Jeff Steier
    • I had been looking for a realtor for a few months and was unhappy with everyone I met. When I met John I knew he was an intelligent, trustworthy, caring, genuine guy. He took the time to get to know me, my situation and what I was looking for. We found my dream home and he worked really hard to make it my home! I know if I weren't working with John I would have missed out on my home. He has followed up with me and gone above and beyond my expectations. He is the type of guy I would choose as a friend even if I didn't find him as my realtor first. I will recommend him highly to anyone looking for a realtor and would definitely use him again in the future. Thank you, John, for all your help! Kristin

      - Kristin McCoy
    • John is totally a very informative, helpful, go out of your way kind of person. I would always hire him and recommend him to friends looking for homes. He follows up right away with you and guides you along the way with all of your questions and if there is something he thinks will be a problem, he will discuss with you. I am very happy.

      - Jodi Crozier
    • John was very knowledgeable, all the information that he shared with us was spot on. He is easy to talk to and a great photographer! He presented our house in the best possible way. I would highly recommend him to others buying or selling a house.

      - Allison Riedi
    • We had the pleasure of having John Gscheidmeier both sell our old home and represent us for our new home. John is a wealth of knowledge and is very well versed in Real Estate. In Fact we liked him so much that we mentioned him to a relative, and they are currently working through an offer.

      - Roy Nuchell
    • John was wonderful to work with. He took into consideration everything we were looking for in a home, and every property he showed us fit what we'd been looking for. We ended up buying the very first property he showed us, and it is the perfect home for us! If and when we decide to move, we will definitely work with John again!

      - Melissa Berg
    • John is highly professional. I will continue to use him to help me buy and sell properties.

      - Jeff Steier
    • Thank you very much for the Bartolotta gift card. You couldnt have given us anything that we will enjoy more and we will probably use it at Joey Gerards. Greg and I also want to take this opportunity to express our appreciation for the time and effort you expended on the sale of our Cumberland home and the purchase of our new home. Your dedication and expertise were evident throughout the process, taking what could have been a very stressful situation and making it a very enjoyable experience. We will definitely recommend you to our family, friends, and work associates.

      - Rosemary Barker
    • Although I have heard John on WISN 1130 in Milwaukee, I first personally met John on December 31, 2013 when he did a walk-through of a rental property my husband and I were considering selling. After talking with John for a few minutes I was very comfortable with his demeanor, professionalism, real estate knowledge, integrity, and honesty. He did not do any pressure selling of his company, but did provide information about the services the company provides and the fees for those services. He was very willing to answer any questions. We wanted a realistic opinion of what the property could sell for which John provided. In fact, the home recently sold for slightly over the high end of the price range that John provided.John gave thorough information and explanation of the documents we signed when we listed the home. He was responsive through the process and helped us understand the process when we received an offer on the property, assisting us through closing. John is friendly, helpful, personable, knowledgeable and patient. We highly recommend John Gscheidmeier as an agent to anyone purchasing or selling a home.

      - Diane Birdeau
    • John was our agent for both selling our condo and buying our house. My wife and I met with him a couple times prior to listing our condo and he explained the entire process. He researched the comparable sales for us and recommended a price range and we discussed/picked the price that we were all comfortable listing at. John also went through the condo with us to point out any items that may come up during inspection so that we could address potential issues up front. I would definitely consider him a full service realtor as he also has invested in camera equipment to help in the marketing of your home. We lucked out and found the right buyer as our condo had an accepted offer within two days of being listed.John is also a valuable resource on the buying side. We were looking in Waukesha, which he is very familiar with, so he was able to recommend areas to look that were consistent with the price range we were comfortable with. Again, there was no shortage of service with using Redefined Realty as they set us up with a portal to be able to view homes within our location and price parameters that was very helpful. Since my wife and I did a lot of research of the houses on the market up front, we were able to identify our top candidates even with the quick sell. John set up the showings for us and we had an accepted offer on our new house within two days of accepting the offer on our condo. He also kept us informed of all of the deadlines that we needed to keep track of while working towards the closing date.Overall we were very happy that we had John as our realtor. He is professional and very knowledgeable on the real estate market in the area.While we don't plan on needing to move again for a long time, John will definitely be our first call when the time comes.

      - Ben Peterson
    • John helped me sell my current home and buy a new house. Throughout the process there was nothing John wouldn't do or a question he couldn't answer. Further, when forced into a short time window between buying and selling, John was able to provide me with lenders and inspectors who were able to close on my new house in three weeks. Thanks!

      - Todd Vinohradsky
    • As a military family we did not have much time to find a home before my husband's deployment. John was quick and ready to assist us with our needs in a short notice. He has followed through on all of our requests, been patient with our questions, and shown a dedication to his job by how much time he has spent helping us until our transfer is complete. We appreciate his honesty and felt that he was our advocate from the beginning. My husband was not only able to see the home he would be coming back home to, but we also closed before his departure which was a huge weight off our shoulders. John made the buying process stress free and would absolutely recommend him.

      - Kassandra Maurer
    • John is very knowledgeable about the process and negotiation techniques. We were in a rush to find a home as we received an offer on ours after our contingency offer on another home feel through. When we walked into our home we all knew (including John) that this was the home for us. At the time the house had 3 other pending offers on it. John was very persistent with the listing agent to find out if any of those offers had been accepted and explained that another "very attractive" offer was coming in so to please hold until midnight. We worked feverishly to come up with the offer and were pleased to find out that our offer beat out the competition. If you want someone who will work for you every step of the way go with John.

      - Dan & Angela Eisenhut
    • John was absolutely great to work with. He was very knowledgeable about the home buying process and was always sure that our questions were answered in an honest and up front way. It was difficult sometimes as my husband was in a different state than I as we were looking, but John took the time to explain things to my husband that I wasn't able to relay and make him comfortable with the decisions that were being made. When there were questions regarding an area of the home we were purchasing, he put us into contact with an appropriate company to come and look at the problem and help us make an informed decision prior to purchasing the home. Although our purchase is complete, we have kept in touch with him and he has provided us with additional contacts to get some other work on the house. I would recommend him without hesitation!! He's wonderful

      - Becky Mueller
    • John was an outstanding Realtor with us. He said he was the best in the area and he wasn't kidding. As new home owners he had our best interest in mind. He explained what things to look for when looking for a house and did a great job. Super nice, friendly and dependable guy. I would recommend him to anyone.

      - John Turek
    • From the day John listed our 2 family on a Monday he was on the ball making the property move off the market. We had showings with in 24hours of listing nonstop a multiple offers in 2 weeks and property sold closed in 6 weeks. All I can say is wow a fantastic human being. Hard worker honest and always only a phone call away 7 days a week.

      - Ed David Jr