Peter Stefaniak Real Estate Agent at The Stefaniak Group, Llc

Peter Stefaniak

Real Estate Agent at
The Stefaniak Group, Llc

Currently accepting new clients

Contact Peter
Usually responds in 30 mins
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Investment Properties

Is Peter the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Peter's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Peter is a top selling Muskego agent - having sold over 69% more properties in Muskego than the average agent.
Peter has great Condo experience - having sold 71 more condos than the average agent.
Peter is a SFH expert - working with over 69% more single family homes than the average Muskego agent.

More about Peter Stefaniak

Not Your Average Agent! The average agent sells about 8 homes per year. I sell a house every week! Licensed Since 1977. Over $400 Million in career sales. Second Generation Realtor. Past President of Milwaukee Board of Realtors. 1996 Realtor of the Year. A desire to serve with the tools to perform...Experience, Knowledge and committed to being a true full time professional. Success is not owned, it is rented and the rent is due EVERYDAY! In a down Real Estate market as was the case in 2011, The Stefaniak Group reports sales were UP 17% from the previous year! Our years of experience make the difference. Small company with big time results!! A family of Realtors since 1952 Specialties: Residential Real Estate including single family, investment property, condominum and commercial.

Dale Carnegie /Concordia College


Past President, GMAR Realtor Board, 1996 Realtor of the Year.


Super Agents are experienced, highly rated agents with a track record of success with HomeLight clients. Peter Stefaniak is committed to providing great service for their clients.

License Number


Peter earned the Best of HomeLight Award in 2018 for being in the Top 1% of agents in the area.

Learn about Best of HomeLight >

Peter Stefaniak's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with Peter Stefaniak

    • When I wanted to sell my home, i first tried a discount Realtor and that did not work out. So, I switched to the largest firm, that did not work out. Then I listed with Peter S. Stefaniak. I found Peter to be very upbeat, reliable and knowledgeable. His experience showed during the sale and closing.

      - Gerry L. Muskego Wi
    • When we needed to sell our property, We contacted Peter Stefaniak due to his knowledge, experience and track record in the Muskego market. Our transaction was difficult. Pete handled it smoothly.

      - Bruce & Beverly Kluge. Muskego Wi 53150
    • Fantastic service! I was 530 miles away and all was handled as if we were working side by side. Yes, I would go through Peter S. Stefaniak again if the situation came up.

      - Marlyne New Berlin, Wis
    • I am very happy with Peter S. Stefaniak and his team. His knowledge, experience and advice was so helpful in selling two homes over the years for me and my family. I will gladly call him if I buy or sell another home.

      - M. Jossart. Milwaukee
    • Stefaniak Realty was awesome every step of the way in the sale of my West Allis Duplex! Pete was thorough and had great advice for ways to move the property and get the best price. I would never look anywhere else for my purchase or sales needs!J. Welch

      - J. Welch Hales Corners, Wis.
    • Hi PeteI want to Thank You for all the work on selling my home. Your patience and understanding of my whole situation was invaluable. Yes, I'd give you 10 stars and would recommend you to others in the Milwaukee area.Marlyne Laughlin

      - 7732 W. Mount Vernon ave.
    • I thank you for the excellent job you did in selling my house. You were so knowledgeable and the best realtor. I am so grateful for the way you always kept me so very well informed and up to date on the proceedings.

      - Dorothy Gudlin, New Berlin WIs.
    • When we wanted to sell our Lake home we listed with the Largest Real Estate firm. We were disappointed with our agent and our home did not sell in 6 months. We then interviewed other agents. We decided to hire Peter S. Stefaniak at the Stefaniak Group. We were impressed with his enthusiasm, passion and willingness to be creative in showing our Lake home. Peter did not disappoint us as he got our home SOLD quickly at a very good price.

      - Greg & Sue Reiss