Sarah Lilly Real Estate Agent at Five Star Real Estate Lakeshore Llc

Sarah Lilly

Real Estate Agent at
Five Star Real Estate Lakeshore Llc

Get introduced
Usually responds in a few hours


  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Vacation Home
  • Relocations
  • Probate
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist

Is Sarah the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Sarah's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Sarah gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Holland agent by 6%.
Sarah has great Condo experience - having sold 62 more condos than the average agent.
Sarah is a SFH expert - working with over 70% more single family homes than the average Holland agent.

Sarah's Transactions

More about Sarah Lilly

When you are buying or selling a home, you want, need, and absolutely must have a real estate agent who is immersed in the community, one who understands how it works. You’ve come to the right place. Community involvement is what I do. It’s the fabric of my everyday life. It’s the foundation of my relationship-based approach to realty. Before becoming a top 10 agent along the lakeshore in terms of production, I had a successful career in sales and marketing. I met the best and brightest in West Michigan, people I can lean on when you’re working with me to buy or sell a home. Advantage you. My relationship-based approach means I don’t target a specific price range, rather I focus on what’s best for my clients. When I am not selling homes, I serve as the Board President of the Greater Ottawa County United Way where I’ve worked as the Lighthouse Leadership Campaign Chair for the past 2 ...
Show More


Sells Homes Fast 2021


Michigan State

License Number


Sarah Lilly's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Sarah Lilly

    • We have purchased and sold many homes over the years and our experience with Sarah and her team was the most pleasant of all. Sarah is very knowledgeable, responsive communicated well throughout each step of the process.

      - Bill, Holland
    • Excellent purchasing experience with Sarah. We purchased a house while living out of state. Sarah made sure all the "t's" were crossed and "i's" dotted. We never had to worry about the next step or if we were forgetting anything. All went according to plan and genuinely happy with every aspect. We would highly recommend Sarah to others and most certainly would work with her on our next purchase.

      - Pam, Holland
    • Sarah was amazing to work with! She was on top of everything. She replied promptly to all of my questions/concerns. We were doing a long distance purchase and she lined everything up for us. I cant imagine buying a home in Holland without her!

      - Julie, Holland
    • Sarah helped us with the selling of our home and the purchase of our new home. We really wanted a historic home and they sell very quick in our area. She was able to get us information on properties before they even hit the market so we could move fast. We eventually found the beautiful home we had been looking for all thanks to her! For the selling of our property, she helped us determine a great price and our property sold the first day it was on the market for over asking! She truly hits every area in the best way possible and I cannot say enough on how great she is!

      - Ben K, Zeeland
    • My wife and I love Sarah. She put up with our persnickety attitudes when viewing prospective properties for months, always patient and always willing to go the extra mile to answer all of our questions. On a number of occasions we would shoot her a text or email and within a few minutes sometimes almost instantly she'd respond with the answer or a note to say she would find the answer - just amazing. We both agree that we've never worked with anyone like her in any business capacity. If you are in the market for an agent and you don't use Sarah believe me you're doing yourself a disservice.

      - Rick, Allegan County
    • Sarah Lilly was fantastic from the moment we started the process of selling our beloved house. Her expertise put us at ease from day one and guided us smoothly through each step along the way. Selling ones home could be a source of stress, but Sarah skillfully and thoughtfully walked us through to the final moments of closing. We highly recommend Sarah Lilly for your next real estate needs!

      - Deb, Zeeland MI