
Alison Stottlemyer
Real Estate Agent at
Coldwell Banker Realty
Browse homes for sale in markets that Alison serves
Find top agents in markets that Alison serves
Specialties
- First Time Home Buyers
- Vacation Home
- Relocations
- Waterfront Specialist
- New Construction
- Luxury Specialist
- Golf Course Communities
- GREEN Homes
- Historic Homes
Agent Highlights
Alison's Transactions
- Single Family Home4 bed / 3 bathBuyer$779,00007/28/2026
- Single Family Home4 bed / 4 bathBuyer$1,500,00006/10/2026
- Single Family Home3 bed / 2 bathBuyer$530,00005/28/2026
- Single Family Home3 bed / 2 bathBuyer$494,30405/27/2026
- Single Family Home3 bed / 2 bathSeller$530,00005/12/2026
- Single Family Home3 bed / 2 bathBuyer$1,245,00004/08/2026
- Single Family Home4 bed / 5.0 bathBuyer$3,250,00003/27/2026
More about Alison Stottlemyer
Alison Stottlemyer's Reviews & Ratings
Tell us about your experience with
Alison Stottlemyer
Selling your home is such a challenging process. For us, we needed someone to take the reins, put the plan in place, remind us regularly of what needed doing, and recognize when a small thing could make a big difference. Who knew that a ceramic pineapple would resonate with our buyers? Well, Alison Stottlemyer, our agent, did.If you want a full-service realtor who knows Sarasota like few do, check out her website (www.gulftogolfrealestatecom) and give her a call. You'll be surprised how fast you sell. Home #1 sold in a week with multiple offers. Home #2? Three hours! And with multiple offers and over asking. What more could you want?
- Kathy - Bay Isles, Longboat Key, FLAlison has become my go-to realtor in Sarasota. I have used her for two separate transactions and both have been flawless. If you are looking to work with a realtor who is a great communicator, market savvy, and will get things done for you, she is the one. I would highly recommend Alison for your Sarasota real estate needs!
- Austin - Southgate, Sarasota, FLAlison Stottlemyer was the perfect choice for us to find our new home in Sarasota, Florida. My husband and I have moved quite a few times over the past years and finding the right realtor has been crucial for the journey. We have found that the perfect person must not only possess knowledge of the areas real estate market and be equipped to help us navigate through its many twists and turns but more important, someone whos patient, kind and willing to listen to what our desires were for our new home, regardless of how insignificant they may seem. Alison made our journey a smooth and pleasant one. She made sure that no question went unanswered throughout the entire process and did it with a smile. She shared in our joy knowing that she helped us find our new home.
- Barbara - The Meadows, Sarasota, FLAlison was an absolute joy to work with. We were a very challenging client with very specific requirements. She was very motivated to find our dream home, sending daily updates even if they were a bit outside of our lines. This kept our search fresh and challenged what we wanted and needed. She's extremely knowledgeable in her field and uses the latest tools to assist her buyers and sellers. There were many homes we were able to get glances at through the her social media posts. I'd recommend her to anyone looking for a talented real estate agent
- Christina - Laurel Lakes, Sarasota, FLAlison is a first-rate, top-notch agent. She represented us with absolute skill and professionalism. She knows the market, took the time to get to know us and our wants/needs, and was able to more than effectively take us to homes that met our criteria. She is outstanding at negotiating, getting things done, communicating, and truly caring about us as people. She has an eye for detail and was involved in every detail of the process from start to finish. I was referred to her by a very satisfied customer and we, as very satisfied customers, have already referred her to a friend. She is truly the best of the best and it was an absolute pleasure working with her throughout this process...and now we are thrilled home owners because of Alison and her ability to so skillfully manage this entire process.
- Julie - Serenity Creek, Bradenton, FLI was referred to Alison by a friend. After my first meeting with Alison, I knew that she was the person I wanted to work with. Alison spent an entire day the first day we toured homes trying to understand what I was looking for in a home. She explained how the entire process worked and answered all of my questions. Alison was great with dealing with me as a first time home buyer and wasn't put off by having to do a lot of hand-holding, with an indecisive buyer. The first weekend we went out to see houses in Sarasota and Bradenton, so I got a feel for different areas and neighborhoods. Alison was able to provide me with lots of background information on each area highlighting the pros and cons of each and she was also able to point out potential problems that I would have completely missed. At the end of the first day we narrowed our focus to more specific areas and Alison had a much better understanding of what I wanted. Alison was very considerate of my time, when I came down for subsequent home tours. She would send me information in my personalized portal about every property she planned to show me. I appreciated the most, Alison allowed me to figure out on my own that my wish list wasn't congruent with what I expected to pay for a home. Once I made an offer, Alison was there to guide me through each step of the process. Additionally, Alison uses Docusign which allowed me to sign paperwork online. Since I was working during the day ( two hours away) this was convenient, as I was able to get the necessary paperwork signed and submitted on time. 23 days after my initial offer, I closed on my first home!!! Alison is genuine, trustworthy, knowledgeable, professional, patient and committed to making her client happy. There were days I was so frustrated, overwhelmed and discouraged. However, Alison would always say, "we will find the perfect home for you and your daughter". She was right, we found the perfect home! Thank you Alison!
- Sunya - Arbor Reserve, Bradenton, FLAlison is knowledgeable, professional and kind. She does not understand the definition of no and goes above and beyond to make the emotional process of selling a home as easy as possible. She is an incredible problem solver and leaves no detail unturned. I have and will recommend her to everyone I know and will use her for any upcoming real estate transactions for me or my family.
- Denise - Magnolia Place, Sarasota, FLAlison Stottlemyer is amazing! She has taken the stress out of the buying and selling process with her prompt responsiveness, her knowledge of the area and the market, her attention to detail, and her honest, friendly advice. Alison made my wife and I feel like we were her only clients during our time with her, but we found out that she sold multiple houses the same week we were negotiating the sale of our home.
- Charles - The Enclave, Sarasota, FLAlison is everything you could want in a real estate agent and more. She is dedicated to doing whatever her clients need. When we visited Sarasota to search for a home, she spent an entire week with us looking at different types of homes in various locations in the area. And then after we left Sarasota, she continued to search for homes we might be interested in, even visiting several and giving us virtual tours by FaceTime. After we decided on a home, Alisons guidance and continued assistance were invaluable in completing our purchase. Throughout the process, Alison was always energetic, cheerful, and responsive, and also on top of all the details. In short, Alison is a consummate professional as well as a delight to work and spend time wit
- Lynne - Country Club Shores, Longboat Key, FLMy wife and I, as the saying goes, have been around the block a time or two. In other words, we are not easily impressed. However, from our first meeting with Alison to the signing of the final papers on the sale of our house...we were impressed. It was obvious to us that Alison had the expertise and negotiation skills to handle every aspect of the sale. She took the time to explain the entire process we would be going through...answering our many questions. As the specifics of the actual sale developed, Alison maintained contact by phone, by email, and by visiting with us in our home. We can sum up our experience in one word...PERFECT!
- Ron - Southgate, Sarasota, FLAlison is wonderful! She was our agent when we purchased our home last year, and then sold it for us less than a year later when a job transfer necessitated a move. The whole process was seamless and fastunder contract in a week and closing a month later! She is also incredibly nice, fun to work with, and always responsive to any question or concern. I cant recommend her enough!
- Sarah - Longwood Run, Sarasota, FLAlison was a complete breath of fresh air & not daunted by any obstacles. I had a very negative experience w/a previous realtor I had known for 30 yrs. After that experience, I was cynical & not very trusting. Alison was fantastic from the get go before we even met. First, unlike other realtors, she is not just seeking your listing to pile up her numbers. She listens very, very carefully, asks great questions, takes judicious notes, makes excellent recommendations & makes you feel as if you are her only client. The day my 1st offer came in, she was negotiating 2 other contracts! She always called me back, offered sage advice, was wonderful psychologically w/how I should proceed. She appealed to my business sense, has a great demeanor about her & is incredibly tenacious as well professional. I have already recommended her to 2 people & she has already met w/1. They were equally impressed & intend to list w/Alison. I am not one who invests her ego in others, saying "you have to use my person because they are the best". But in this case, Alison was so supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at Every level. She guided me through everything & allayed my few fears. She was a great sounding board as well. You will Never be disappointed if you should choose her are your selling agent. You will be very, very pleased.
- Gisele - Prestancia, Sarasota, FL