Carolyn Tumminia Real Estate Agent at Keller Williams Realty Stl

Carolyn Tumminia

Real Estate Agent at
Keller Williams Realty Stl

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Foreclosures
  • Investment Properties
  • Farm Property
  • Vacation Home
  • Relocations
  • Probate
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • New Construction
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist
  • Land Specialist

Is Carolyn the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Carolyn's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Carolyn gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Des Peres agent by 11%.
Carolyn has great Condo experience - having sold 24 more condos than the average agent.
Carolyn is a SFH expert - working with over 71% more single family homes than the average Des Peres agent.

Carolyn's Transactions

  • Crestwood, MO
  • Ballwin, MO
    Single Family Home
  • Brentwood, MO
  • Clayton, MO
  • Wentzville, MO
  • Chesterfield, MO
    Single Family Home
  • Chesterfield, MO
    Single Family Home

More about Carolyn Tumminia

Carolyn works under Keller Williams Realty Stl. Carolyn has sold 4.46x the number of single family homes as the average agent in the area. We’ve recorded data for 301 of Carolyn’s transactions. Carolyn prefers to work with both buyers and sellers. Here’s what we know about Carolyn’s work: - Carolyn recently sold one home for $880,000. - this real estate agent is skilled in fast home sales: they have listings that have sold in as little as 0 days. - Carolyn is a top dollar real estate agent. Carolyn has completed 32 transactions in St. Louis. Carolyn ranks at the top of the pack--they qualify as a top 5% real estate agent in St. Louis. HomeLight considers this real estate agent a closer because they have sold 18 more homes than the average agent in the area. • Experienced, established, and well-connected• Powerful negotiator protecting her clients best interest• Extremely ...
Show More

University of Missouri-Saint Louis, St. Louis Community College, Saint Louis University, Spring Hill College, St.Joseph's Academy

Other Certifications

Pricing Strategy Advisor Certification (PSA), Seller Representative Specialist (SRS), Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES)

License Number


Carolyn Tumminia's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Carolyn Tumminia

  • Carolyn helped me buy a home

      Carolyn worked tirelessly with my wife and me to find the perfect home, then guided us through the purchase process and home inspection. She helped us get enough money from the seller to replace the septic system and needed repairs that we would not have otherwise gotten. We feel she is top notch and will definitely use her again.

    • Carolyn listed and sold my home

        She was great. Communication was excellent. Highly recommend her.

      • Dear Ms. Vitale,It is impossible to adequately put into words what Carolyn Tumminia did for me and my family after we lost our home and everything in it as a result of hurricane Katrina, but after all she did for us, its worth a shot. When we decided to relocate to St. Louis from New Orleans, Carolyn helped us to find the perfect home. But even before that, she demonstrated to us that she was a kind, caring professional. Many realtors wouldnt have granted us the time of day, given the difficulty of our circumstances and our meager budget. Carolyn always treated us with dignity and respect, at a time when saying you were a Katrina victim from New Orleans stirred mixed reactions, not all of them compassionate or positive. She was there for us, supporting us, advising us, and cheering us on, during the most stressful and depressing time in our lives. I doubt that any realtor in your office ever worked as hard for a commission as Carolyn did for us. Sometimes that meant meeting with inspectors or contractors at our prospective home because we were not in town yet to do it ourselves. Other times it meant making herself available by phone at odd hours to answer our questions and calm our restless minds. And still, other times it meant making our two-year-old daughter feel like the center of the universe while we toured at least twenty homes in the space of a day. Our daughter Clarisse has not forgotten Carolyn, and her little face still lights up at the mention of her name. (The enclosed photograph of Clarisse asleep on Carolyns lap during negotiations on our home purchase illustrates how immediate and sincere her rapport with Clarisse was.) But most of all, it meant staying calm, patient, and reassuring in the face of the Kafkaesque nightmare that finalizing our Small Business Administration loan from the federal government became. When we arrived at our June 26 closing, the money from the SBA had not yet arrived, in spite of the fact that we had already closed on the loan in New Orleans in May. As we sat in her office in tears at the news that day, Carolyn was able to find a way to negotiate with the seller so that we wouldnt lose the house we (and she) worked so hard to find. All the while she was on the phone with the sellers agent, she remained calm and cool. And in the midst of it all, she still managed to soothe my daughter when, clearly, my husband and I were wrapped up in our own stress.After a series of dates that came and went in the form of false hopes from the SBA, we did finally close on our beautiful old home in the Carondelet/Holly Hills neighborhood on August 8, 2006, and we are very happy in it. Thank you, Carolyn, for your compassion, for your professionalism, for your strength, for your honesty, for your real estate expertise. Thank you for your confidence in knowing when to give us answers and when to ask the right questions on our behalf. And thank you most of all for being the kind of person who I can trust with my life. As a result of our personal experience of loss, we know just how crucial buying and owning a home is to life and our ability to live it. Prudential has a priceless treasure in Carolyn Tumminia.Sincerely,Elise B. Aasgaard, Ph.D.Saint Louis University 6433 Alabama Ave.St. Louis, MO 63111

        - Elise B. Aasgaard, Ph.D. Saint Louis University, St. Louis, MO
      • FYI Just want to share the following... If anyone finds themselves in need of a real estate agent I speak from experience when I say I can refer you to an excellent one....Carolyn Tumminia with Prudential Select Properties in the Des Peres office. Carolyn is first and foremost a longtime friend (38 years) and could not have done a better job handling the sale, especially given the current real estate market. Carolyn realizes that you are selling your "home"...not just a piece of real estate. She went above and beyond in marketing, open houses etc. and I know for sure that she puts her heart into her work for all of her clients. It is no surprise to me that Carolyn has been successful in her real estate career and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell! Laurie

        - Laurie, Kirkwood, MO
      • Hi,My brother John's condo went to closing today, and he will soon be giving Laclede a check for the rest of his down payment and interest. That is a wonderful and helpful program to assist new residents. I want to highly recommend the realtor that you provided. Carolyn Tumminia (info below) was extremely helpful all through the process from start to finish. She worked closely with John to get the condo ready for sale, going to Lowe's with him to get help him purchase replacement kitchen appliances, arranging for a handy man to make necessary repairs, and advising John and us of all the steps needed to prepare the condo for sale. As John's Trustee I was separated from hands-on participation by 2000 miles, but Carolyn's constant communication kept me well in the loop, and I had no concerns about how things were progressing. Her advice always proved to be sound, and the manner in which she worked with my brother eased his concerns and helped made his move as smooth as possible. Again, I highly recommend Carolyn for others going through this process.Thank you!Your friends in Christ,Paul and Jane Hoffmann

        - Paul and Jane Hoffmann, St.Louis, MO