
Craig Mayhew
Real Estate Agent at
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices / Professional Realty
- Seller Representative Specialist
Agent Highlights
Craig's Transactions
- 119 Mayfair BlvdColumbusSingle Family HomeSeller$143,00011/21/2018
- 7951 Padstow DrColumbusCondominiumBuyer$146,00011/15/2018
- 5994 Tipperary DrColumbusSingle Family HomeBuyer$149,00011/02/2018
- 312 W Hubbard AveColumbusSingle Family HomeBuyer$405,00010/12/2018Craig helped a buyer purchase this property for 24% under asking price
- 6230 Inishmore LaneDublinCondominiumBuyer$104,13510/11/2018
- 7892 Stonehurst DrColumbusSingle Family HomeSeller$274,90009/07/2018
- 5745 Ballantrae CircleDublinSingle Family HomeBuyer$559,90008/15/2018
More about Craig Mayhew
Craig Mayhew's Reviews & Ratings
Tell us about your experience with
Craig Mayhew
Craig was excellent in every aspect. He was always available and extremely knowledgeable. Craig got us our home on our first offer, he made the buying process painless and kept us informed. After closing on our home and moving in, Craig has stayed in contact, making sure everything is going well and answering all our questions.
- S PortierIf you are going to buy or sell a home you need Craig! Being a first time home buyer myself he made the process so easy and understandable. My husband and I work untypical schedules so getting in to view homes when we were first looking was a bit difficult. Somehow, despite short notice, Craig was always able to get us in to see a home even same day if possible. He is very responsive and always available for questions. Great at negotiating! Please take his advice with this. Craig is very personable and genuine guy that my husband and I were lucky to have found.
- K KirkendallWe would definitely recommend Craig. Even if you have an updated home that you think will show well, a realtor can bring a ton of value in helping you sell. Not having to worry about each step thru the closing was a big burden off our plates when we also needed to pack up 15 years of things, work and manage a family. Craig made it easy for us to sell and his proactive communication all along the way was great. Craig is respectful, hardworking, honest and always a great partner with us. We will contact him the next time we move.
- G GoffeIf you're looking for someone to help you in a competitive area like Grandview, that will respond to you very quickly and get you in to see places the day they pop up, Craig is the perfect realtor for you. He is very good at communicating with you as well as negotiations with potential sellers and works very hard to understand what exactly you're looking for. Very reliable.
- T PolstonCraig has so much experience to bring to the table. He also has a passion for great customer service. His negotiation skills are top notch and it is always a pleasant experience to work with him. In addition to helping to buy and sell your home, he has also been great at referrals to real estate agents out of state. If he doesnt know right away he will do the research for you to find the right referral. Craig is highly recommended.
- J LeeI have known Craig for several years and would typically not use a friend to sell my home but, Craig kept it professional and I knew that he was a very knowledgable agent and I would HIGHLY recommend him. He also has so many resources to help with making sure the home looks great to sell. My home listed one day and offer was made with in a couple days - full asking price. That is because Craig knows how to price the homes he sells -- knows the market.
- J AvandalMy husband and I were so grateful to have Craig help us in the search for a new home as well as selling our previous property. Not only did he set up an online search tool specifically tailored to our needs, but he was extremely responsive and proactive about setting up showings. When it came time to make an offer, his knowledge and foresight helped us secure a contract for the perfect home for our family, despite the competition we faced. During the sale of our home we faced a few unexpected setbacks, but Craig was there every step of the way. His patience and professional resources were paramount and we could have never done it without him! Craig was such a pleasure to work with and we can't thank him enough!!
- K KimbleI loved working with Craig! I was a first time home buyer and Craig was extremely patient with me. Craig was very knowledgeable about Columbus and the surrounding areas. He made me feel very comfortable to ask questions and constantly reminded me that this process was about me and not him. Anytime we walked into a house that I wasn't sure about, he laid out the pros and cons and always reminded me that if I don't love it now, I won't love it when I move in. I would highly recommend Craig to anyone because he truly was that amazing to work with. Prior to working with Craig, I was working with another Realtor that I wasn't impressed with as I felt like someone to just close a deal with. I share that because Craig truly blew my expectations out of the water and made me feel like a friend and not a client. He allowed me to ask a million questions and was always available. Craig is very respectful and 100% honest. Again, I highly recommend Craig as his expertise and experience was truly excellent.
- B SterlingCraig is easy to work with, very responsive, and knowledgeable about the real estate market. He helped us purchase a home and sell a condo and went out of his way to arrange inspections and estimates from third party contractors. Craig is a good negotiator and thinks outside the box. We would recommend Craig in an instant.
- G CravenerCraig was a blastI didnt think home buying was supposed to be fun-filled. He guided us through the purchase of our first home. He showed us areas we didnt initially think of and always having a sense of humor through the entire experience. While there were bumps along the way from lenders and multiple inspections, he always kept calm and negotiated us through the steps to get us into the home we love. Craig was always flexible and able to set expectations along the way. Id be happy to recommend him to anyone about to start their journey with buying a home.
- B MullinsI am an Architect in Columbus & work w/ a lot of professionals in many industries including Real Estate. Craig is a consummate professional. He has a great personality, is not high pressure, & listens to your feelings & thoughts whether buying or selling a property. His attention to detail, thoroughness, & constant communication on the status of the sale of my property was unparalleled. We worked seamlessly together & after 24 showings in three days received eight offers. Craig immediately prepared a spreadsheet outlining all of the offers, their contingencies, financing, etc @ 6:00 on a Sunday night and we met at 7:00 to review them. We collectively came to the same conclusion & successfully closed on the property.
- G RauschAs first-time home buyers and relatively new Columbus residents, we were grateful for Craig's knowledge and patience as we figured out what we were really looking for and what was possible. Craig was responsive, even anticipated our questions, and always came through for us when we had questions or concerns. We appreciated the time he took in showing us homes and helping us weigh pros and cons throughout our search. He made the negotiation process straightforward, and we just closed on a place that we are very excited about!
- E PaynterCraig was a great real estate agent. I am 24 and a first time buyer, I had a pretty strict range, but one he could work with. I wanted to be in the German Village/Merion Village/Schumacher Place area. I had a tight timeline, timing up when my current lease would be up, and starting the mortgage. Craig worked with all of this, and did a great job. The house I found, the current owners were very strict about allowing people to view it (we were only the third group in 2 weeks in Schumacher Place), but Craig stayed persistent and got us in that day. I have to admit, that I had hit a point where I was not expecting to find what I wanted out of the market, but Craig stayed optimistic, and found something that I am very happy with. I would not go with any other agent other than Craig in the future. He is a nice guy, that is honest and up front with you, he doesn't try to sell you on anything, but lets you know what is good and what is bad.
- J BomprezziCraig was excellent. Friendly and making one of the most stressful events in your life much more relaxed. He possesses excellent insight into many of the markets in Columbus that was instrumental in setting up my listing. His experience in selling led to an uncanny ability to read the other party. Without any reservations, I would highly recommend Craig to any buyer or seller.
- I ZuckermanI am a real estate attorney and hard to impress. Ive been involved in real estate transactions for 30 plus years. Craig helped me in acquiring a second home. He was accessible and followed through quickly. After the closing, when a home warranty issue needed resolution, Craig was just as attentive. I cant say enough about the service Craig provided. He has earned my recommendation.
- A McCallinI recently bought my first home with Craig. He is prompt and insightful. Craig is very helpful and diligent. I would recommend him to anyone. He explained the process and made it very simple. He gave me all of the tools needed. Great job!
- V StinnettWe had a great experience with Craig! He got us top dollar for the sale of our existing home and negotiated for a reduced price on our new home. He was always responsive to our needs and consistently provided in-depth knowledge of the housing markets. We would highly recommend Craig to anyone looking for an informed, honest and trustworthy realtor.
- M WillisCraig was amazing! We were first time homebuyers and Craig walked us through each step. He is very knowledgeable and helped us win our home when we were put into a blind bidding war. He is always easy to reach and responds quickly. We can't say enough great things about him!
- J Van Den BergCraig was awesome! From the moment we met him he set up an email alert that gave us houses in our area and in our price range. He found exactly what we were looking for in our price range. And once we decided to put in an offer, he was with us every step of the way. As first time homebuyers, it was a very scary experience. However, we always had someone there to answer questions and to back us up and let us know what was going on. At no point was there a time that I didn't know what was happening, and I always knew that Craig would answer any questions that I needed him too. He was amazing! I would rate him a 10/10!
- C ThomasI highly recommend Craig for any real estate transaction need that you may have. Working with Craig was a great pleasure. Craig highly knowledgeable of the local Columbus market and extremely responsive. He is excellent in answering his phone or getting back with you very quickly when you need him. This is very important, and Craig realizes that you rely upon his expertise. He listed and sold my house in Columbus 43212 with great skill. I relied and trusted upon his knowledge in developing a listing price and strategy. I ended up receiving three full price offers the first day the home was on the market. This means that Craig was 100% on point with the price, as it was perfect - not too high and not too low. I am thrilled with the price I got for the house, as well as being beyond thrilled with Craig's service. Craig has an impressive background, and he was an expert negotiator from the offer stage to inspections to closing. I trust Craig enough that I would recommend him to my family and friends, and sincerely encourage you to place your trust in him as well. You will not be disappointed.
- J HudachCraig did a great job helping us buy our new home while helping us sell our current home. Does great research, provides good advice and always available when you need him. I highly recommend him and have already recommended him to my family. He has helped my brother sell his home and my Mother buy her condo. I will continue to recommend him to any family or friends that need a realtor in the future.
- T CastroThis was my first time home buying experience and it was amazing! I was all over the place in terms of where I wanted to live, but Craig did a great job of helping me narrow my wants/needs of my future home! Once we found my new house he negotiated items into the sale of the home that I certainly would have missed. There was no stress involved and looking was fun. It was a pleasure having Craig as my realtor!
- A JohnsonCraig helped my family find and purchase a house and we couldn't recommend him more. We were extremely impressed by his diligence and attention to detail during our search, negotiations, and closing. I have to say Craig is a real powerhouse during negotiations and will work hard to get you the best deal. We will definitely refer him to friends AND family and hopefully utilize his services again.
- S ShipleyGreat at showing us different options. Very responsive to buyer's needs and guided us through the home buying process. Friendly and easy to work with.
- E WeiMr. Mayhew was very helpful in helping me find a place that suited my needs. He is very knowledgable in the area and kept open a great line of communication. When we did find the place I was interested in, he was on it instantly with the detailed information and a walk through, and then an offer was submitted, all in less than 24 hours. It is the only place we bid on and we got it. The closing process went very smooth and the key is in my hand. I highly recommend Mr. Mayhew to anyone looking for a place to buy. He is the guy you want in your corner to get the results you are looking for.
- K MarionFinding Craig during our realtor search was an absolute dream scenario. My wife and I were first time home buyers, and Craig made the process so much easier than I ever imagined it could be. His communication was impeccable, we never had to wait for responses, and he kept us well informed every step of the way. His knowledge is vast, both in the buying process, the housing market and even in helping us assess homes (he has a background in construction). He was extremely thorough in every scenario - both in proposing a course of action, and having plans based on how other parties could respond. He always had great recommendations when we needed outside companies, but was never pushy or difficult when we chose to go different routes. Craig is a true master, and we couldn't recommend him more.
- J MillerWe purchased our first home with Craig and couldn't have had a better experience. When we arrived, Craig explained the process of buying a home and answered all of our questions. In each home, we walked through it top-to-bottom and he pointed out the positive and would-need-work aspects of the home. He has a vast knowledge of home construction, which was extremely helpful, and was able to break down the cost per home based on location. Craig was very responsive and checked-in often with information on next steps and what to expect. Craig really made the experience of buying our first home seamless.
- S MinorI was very impressed with Craig Mayhew, he's done everything he said he would do, and then some. He's top notch in his field. He made it possible for me to sell my mother's home in record time, and to be able to do it while at home in Florida, plus get a good price for it! He's very motivated, trustworthy and was really nice to work with. If I'm in the market for another home in the future, there's no one other than Craig that I'd call. If I could give him 10 stars I would.
- C TaylorVery knowledgeable about every aspect that we needed --kept in constant contact and was able to finalize our sell for more that the asking price. Highly recommend.
- S EasthamI would recommend Craig to anyone- he's truly amazing. As a first time home buyer, I had lots of questions and concerns and he helped me every step of the way. Craig took time to learn about my interests in potential homes and presented me with many options that suited my needs. In addition, he has a huge network of home maintenance professionals as a resource for home buyers. I cannot recommend Craig enough. He is an expert at what he does.
- K BestCraig is the best! We just worked with him for the second time. He helped us sell our home efficiently and seemlessly in a crazy market. He also helped us secure our new home. He is incredibly knowledgeable in the market and savvy with negotiations. We would HIGHLY recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Columbus market. Craig has been a true blessing to us as we have navigated the home buying and selling processes. We could not have been as successful as we were had it not been for him!
- T TaylorCraig is a knowledgeable real estate agent that helped guide me through a trying buying process. His awareness of the negotiations process was essential in a very competitive market
- J AppelCraig is an incredibly kind, professional, patient and intelligent person. He helped me and my husband with our first home purchase, and not only did we feel as though he genuinely cared about our happiness and level of comfort throughout the entire process, but he also made himself available any time we needed something or had a question, usually returning our calls or texts within minutes! We were so grateful for everything he did for us! I would absolutely recommend Craig to anyone looking for a realtor! He is amazing and one-of-a-kind!
- K SterlingAs well as delivering what I would hope any realtor would provide for his/her clients, Craig is very responsive to a client's preferences but able, too, to guide him/her gently to a more favorable outcome. He is an excellent negotiator, totally trustworthy and reliable, and always able to anticipate a client's needs. Craig clearly tunes in to his clients and I appreciated that very much. Though he's clearly the real estate expert and I deferred to him (most of the time), he helped me think through some of my inclinations as not necessarily in my best interests. I appreciated his genuine interest in helping me find (and close) on a property that really is my perfect place. He also has a wonderful list of connections (e.g., tradesmen, (electrical etc) who followed through and performed outstanding work) . I've been blessed with excellent realtors in previous real estate transactions, and he tops my list.
- A SoterOur experience with Craig was wonderful. As first-time home buyers, we were intimidated by the process as a whole; Craig demystified the process with his thoroughness, diligence, and expertise. Craig fiercely advocated for our interests as we entered into contact on our home; he was able to secure the best possible deal for us. From that time until we closed, Craig gave us updates and checked in with us on a near-daily basis. We truly felt like we had a friend in our corner, constantly looking out for our best interests. We would highly recommend Craig to anyone who is buying a home, and especially to any first-time buyers. He is excellent.
- D Moss