Holly Mitchell Real Estate Agent at Keller Williams Realty

Holly Mitchell

Real Estate Agent at
Keller Williams Realty

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • Vacation Home
  • Relocations
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • Luxury Specialist
  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Investment Properties
  • New Construction
  • Land Specialist

Is Holly the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Holly's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Holly gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Yarmouth agent by 11%.

Holly's Transactions

  • 115 Saco St
    3 bed / 2 bath
  • 17 Wilson St
    Single Family Home
    3 bed / 2 bath
  • Single Family Home
    3 bed / 2 bath
  • Single Family Home
    3 bed / 4 bath
  • 6 Sumac Dr
    Single Family Home
    4 bed / 3 bath
  • Single Family Home
    3 bed / 3 bath
  • Single Family Home
    5 bed / 2 bath

More about Holly Mitchell

Holly Mitchell has been thinking about houses for almost 30 years. Her work began during a master's thesis and dissertation on widows' ownership of property in colonial America. Her husband Will was happy when she stopped studying widowhood. In 2002, she and Will formed an appraisal company and she worked as a residential appraiser across southern Maine for 8 years, valuing over 2500 homes and learning a great deal about many communities. Wanting to work for people instead of banks, in 2010 Holly joined Keller Williams and began work as a Realtor, winning the "Rookie of the Year" award. Since then she has helped over 100 families buy, sell and invest in real estate. Her favorite statistic is this: over 75 percent of her business comes from past clients and referrals. The trust others place in her is what she values most. In 2017 she helped found the Abode Real Estate Group at ...
Show More

Smith College


Rookie of the Year 2010

License Number


Holly Mitchell's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Holly Mitchell

  • Holly listed and sold my home

      Holly did a fantastic job of setting up a viewing of our house, giving an honest appraisal of the value, and listing the house quickly. Holly and her team provided regular updates regarding next steps for us to complete and potential solutions when roadblocks occurred. As a first time home seller I would highly recommend Holly and her team as a reliable agent to work with.

    • The purchase of a home for my wife and I was one that was challenging. We were looking in a specific town, at a higher price point than we were currently at, and within a market that had very low inventory. Holly was extraordinarily helpful in every step of our purchase - identifying and evaluating properties, discussing valuations, negotiating with the counter parties, and bringing a deep knowledge and calmness when we most needed it. Most importantly Holly was trustworthy. My wife and I have worked with many agents and this was the first time we conceded our full trust to our representative. We asked for her opinion and then followed her lead. It proved to be enormously beneficial and was exactly the type of partner wed always hoped to find. We can not recommend her more highly.

      - D&J S - Cape Elizabeth
    • "Buying a house can be a stressful process, especially if you're on a tight time frame. We were so, so fortunate to work with Holly during our house buying process. I cannot recommend her more highly. She was on her A game all the way through - from jumping on properties the minute they were listed so we could have the first showing, to coordinating everything to make sure we could close in under 30 days. She responded to phone calls and emails promptly and professionally. Most importantly, she listened and really seemed to understand what we were looking for. She was an advocate for us all the way through. I would recommend Holly without reservations."

      - Stacey Caulk- Maine
    • Had a great experience with Holly Mitchell as she helped us find a second home in Portland. Holly is extremely knowledgeable in all aspects of home buying and is very professional. Would highly recommend her to anyone shopping for a home!

      - Gary Kralik - Portland, ME
    • We moved from out of state and Holly was able to help us find a wonderful home at the right price in just one weekend. We had a wonderful experience working with her both from a distance and locally. She was very responsive to our needs and extremely communicative. We can't recommend her highly enough!

      - Danielle Volker-Maine
    • Holly was a terrific resource and advocate during my familys search for a home in Maine. It took a long time to find the right place and she was unfailingly proactive, informed, and patient. Hollys background in appraisal was extremely helpful and her sense of humor and optimism were both appreciated and occasionally needed! I would happily recommend her to any friends and family looking for a home.

      - Laurel S-Harrison, ME
    • "You're not just getting Holly Mitchell, who alone is an amazing realtor, but her entire team. They are beyond professional and so good at what they do, that the sale and purchase of our new house seemed stress free. I cant say enough good things..."

      - Wil Pandolfo - Maine
    • "We were very pleased and grateful for the efforts that Holly and Will provided us in selling our home. They continued to give new ideas to make our house sell. They kept us updated on existing competition and market conditions. They truly were our partners in our success. We would highly recommend them as top professional real estate agents in the business."

      - Frank & Peggy Kasilowski - Maine
    • We worked with Holly to purchase our first home, and can definitely say that we made the right choice in realtor. From the start Holly was responsive, knowledgeable, and always made us aware of details that we would otherwise have been ignorant to; and could have potentially negatively impacted us in the buying process. When it came time to close, Holly put our interests above her own. The result was that we got the home we loved, and we also know who we'll call when it comes time to sell. We can't recommend Holly highly enough.

      - Roveillo - Maine
    • Holly Mitchell was a wonderful person to have as my realtor. She was able to assist me throughout the process with great expertise, insight, and sensitivity, making this "adventure" as comfortable as possible for me. I appreciate Holly's professionalism. The biggest plus for me was Holly's honesty above all. I highly recommend Holly Mitchell.

      - P Adams-Yarmouth, ME
    • ABODE team was fabulous. Walked me through all the details, sent reminders, advised on house staging, and took care of everything. They were always available to answer questions and listen to my concerns. My townhouse sold in record time at a great price. Thanks Holly and Chelsea.

      - Margy Moreman- South Portland, Me