Jessica Keefe Real Estate Agent at Keller Williams NJ Metro Group

Jessica Keefe

Real Estate Agent at
Keller Williams NJ Metro Group

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • Buyers
  • Seller Agent
  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Luxury Specialist

Is Jessica the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Jessica's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Jessica sells properties fast - selling more than 77% quicker than the average Montclair agent.
Jessica gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Montclair agent.
Jessica is a SFH expert - working with over 77% more single family homes than the average Montclair agent.

Jessica's Transactions

More about Jessica Keefe

The Keefe Team, led by Jessica Keefe, has been a real estate leader in the Suburban Essex County area for more than 17 years, having grown from a one-person shop to the team we are today. Everyone on our team is a full-time, licensed agent with the knowledge and experience you should expect of your agent. Whether you are buying, selling or just looking for market or town information, The Keefe Team is committed to providing a real estate experience focused on successfully and smoothly getting you where you want to go as quickly as possible. And if we can have some fun while we’re at it – that’s even better! For home buyers, The Keefe Team are local experts with first-hand knowledge and experience – we live where we work! And we love where we live. We have real-time access to current inventory, markets stats and community information and we will work tirelessly to help you find ...
Show More

Loyola University, Chicago, Loyola in Rome, Italy, Creighton University, Omaha, NE


HomeLight Top Buyer's Agent 2018, HomeLight Top Producer 2018, NJ Monthly Five Star Agent Award 2014-2021, NJR Circle of Excellence Award 2004-2021, Platinum 2020-2021

License Number

Jessica Keefe's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Jessica Keefe

    • Extremely attentive to details, highly responsible, open to suggestions, one of the best professionals in Real Estate market. Highly recommend to anyone who is looking for best handling of selling or buying the house of your dreams. Just pure pleasure to deal with. Good luck, dear Jessica!!!

      - Mona R.
    • Purchased my first home with Jessica, and she was great! Extremely knowledgeable about the Montclair area. After a lot of searching, I wound up buying in Red Bank and Jessica stuck with me in my search for a new area. Made me extremely comfortable every step of the way. Highly recommended. Thanks Jessica!

      - First Time Home Buyer
    • Jessica is very professional and knowledgeable of her duties as a real estate manager. She communicates very well and with patience she will satisfy your real estate needs. Working with Jessica good results are guaranteed.

      - Dino D.
    • Jessica was a true professional. She provided excellent market analysis, advice on how to prepare my home for sale, and went out of her way to make sure I was comfortable and informed every step. She negotiated the deal extremely thoughtfully and gave us a level of comfort with her guidance. I would recommend her for both buyers and sellers!! Thank you Jessica!!

      - Kathy O.
    • Truly a pleasure working with Jessica to find the perfect home for our family. Jessica was extremely helpful in navigating this competitive housing market, providing knowledge about each neighborhood, each street in each neighborhood, all of her advice on the process from the offer to close was spot on, she was able to suggest excellent lawyers, inspectors, contractors, etc. Even helped us figure out a good spot for our temporary housing while we were looking to buy. I would highly recommend Jessica to anyone looking to buy in Montclair!

      - Montclair Buyer
    • Our experience with Jessica was great! She had a "can do" attitude and was completely engaged in the process from start to finish. Our house sold over the asking and in 1 day! We would highly recommend her as an agent.

      - Bloomfield Home Seller
    • Jessica is a fabulous realtor. I cannot say enough about how great she is. From staging to closing, Jessica was always there, giving me great advice and always available for any questions that I might have. Plus she sold my house in a week! Now that's a great realtor. She's easy to work with, professional, knowledgeable and a great all around person. You'd be lucky to have her help you sell your house.

      - Townhouse Seller
    • Working with Jessica to purchase a home was a fantastic experience. As a sales professional, I am not often on the customer side. It was wonderful to have someone who understood our needs, the marketplace, the community and all that is involved with purchasing a home. Not only is Jessica responsive, she is proactive in anticipating and planning for what comes next. I highly recommend working with her. It took the stress out of finding and purchasing a home and made it enjoyable.

      - James O.
    • Jessica was GREAT! We loved her! She understood what we wanted within our prices range. She communicated everything to us and always was on top of things for us. She always made herself available for us through meetings , calls or emails. She had a great sense of urgency with us! We would definitely recommended her as a agent especially if you are a first time home buyer.

      - Belleville Home Buyer
    • Jessica is your dream realtor: reliable, respectful, informed and most importantly she listens and represent your best interests. I met Jessica few years back at the open house. After talking to me and hearing all the things I was looking to have in a properly, she quickly gathered a list of condos that she thought might be interesting for me. To my surprise, she was spot on. But after talking to few mortgage companies at the time, I realized that I was simply not ready for such a step. I explained this to Jessica and she, unlike most of the agents I have dealt with in the past, suggested that we keep in touch until the time is right for me. During that time, she would send me an e-mail every 6 months, causally asking if anything has changed, and was fully respectful of my situation. To me that was extremely important. I simply needed not be harassed with offers and opportunities. When time came and I felt ready, I was able to reach out to Jessica and have her attention immediately. She helped me find and GET the place I liked. By that time, I had a full trust in her, and I believe it is the most important quality one can have in their relationship with their realtor. You must be confident that they will always work in your best interest, that they will negotiate the right price for you, that they will defend your point of view no matter what. And I have to say that Jessica did all that and beyond. Not only she is very knowledgeable about Montclair market, she is also resourceful in so many ways. With her help, I was able to find a mortgage company that worked with my time frame, an attorney, who was simply brilliant, a very good inspector. She helped me and was there at every step of this process, which was great. I however dont think that my experience with Jessica was unique. I believe that her work ethics are impeccable, and that anyone who had a pleasure working with her will tell you the same: she is simply great!

      - Amila S.
    • I have used Jessica Keefe as my real estate agent on two separate occasions. She did such a wonderful job the first time that I never considered using another agent the second time. Jessica's extensive knowledge and experience are invaluable in deciding how to price your home and/ or what to offer on a new home. She knows exactly how to stage your home to make it the most appealing and she is cheerful and tireless when showing new homes. Jessica will go all out to represent you, she is always willing to go the extra mile for her clients. At the same time, her courtesy and just plain niceness make all the other professionals in the community happy to work with her. You could not have a better real estate agent!

      - Lynda
    • I have had the pleasure not only to buy our first home with Jessica a few years back but to have sold and purchased our second home as our family grew Quickly! We couldn't have asked for a better more attentive person to work with that has become pretty much family over the years. We have not been the easiest as we are picky and have many request when searching for homes but this challenge was accepted by Jessica and she has found us our forever home. When the time came to expand and find a bigger home, I dreaded the work load and difficulty of selling and buying at the same time. I don't think I even broke a sweat as Jessica went above and beyond to make sure all the T's were crossed and i's dotted. Every step was laid out and pretty much handled, all we had to do was love a house, and move ??

      - Wharton First Time Home Buyer
    • We can't speak highly enough of our experience with Jessica Keefe. We actually met with a couple of realtors that showed us a few homes prior to finding Jessica. When a big decision such as buying a home you want to work with someone you can trust. Throughout the last 16 months, Jessica was there every step of the way. Her professionalism, knowledge, honesty, and incredible hard work ethic are extremely appreciated and respected. We never felt that she was just trying to sell us house or that we were just another commission on a sale. Jessica walked us through every step of the negotiations; even had us take a family picture (myself, wife and two boys) along with a letter to the seller explaining why she thought they should choose us. It was a smart and calculating approach but it worked and we thank Jessica every day. We are so happy we are in our new home and it is all to Jessicas hard work, dedication, professionalism, knowledge and there more dozens more adjectives I can use. We would most definitely recommend Jessica to anyone in our family and friends looking to buy and or sell a home. We would like to thank Jessica so very much for all the time, energy and hard work she put in to help us find our home. It was some journey that is for sure. We are so happy to finally be homeowners.

      - F. Scafuro
    • Jessica was a dream to work with. We were relocating to the East Coast and had very limited knowledge of the area. Thankfully, I reached out to Jessica prior to our move to enquire about a property we were interested in and we she became an indispensable resource in our move and property search. As part of our relocation, we actually had a dedicated realtor, but in building our relationship with Jessica we quickly realized how good she was and we committed our search with her. She gave us a fantastic overview of the Montclair area and listened to our family needs. Once we found the property of our dreams, Jessica was a fantastic resource in guiding us through the whole process from submitting our bid until the final close. She is extremely efficient and will go above and beyond her role to ensure you are happy and that everything is clear along the way. I would recommend Jessica without hesitation. Andrew Less Highly likely to recommend10/06/2015 - SarahAndrews9Bought a Single Family home in 2015 in North Caldwell, NJ.Local knowledge:Process expertise:Responsiveness:Negotiation skills:My husband and I would recommend Jessica to anyone searching for a home in New Jersey - she deserves 6 out of 5 stars. Her warmth and strong desire to help was apparent from our first phone conversation (I spoke with 3 agents on the phone and only chose to meet with Jessica). She is understanding, More Highly likely to recommend09/30/2015 - monarafaBought a home in 2007 in Upper Montclair, Montclair, NJ 07043.Local knowledge:Process expertise:Responsiveness:Negotiation skills:Extremely attentive to details, highly responsible, open to suggestions, one of the best professionals in Real Estate market. Highly recommend to anyone who is looking for best handling of selling or buying the house of your dreams. Just pure pleasure to deal with. Good luck, dear Jessica!!!

      - Andrew
    • Have used 6 or 7 realtors and Jessica is a real professional. She knows her stuff, studies the market, gives sound advice, works with good stagers, and is always willing to work with you to show your home and to operate pen houses. I highly recommend her.

      - Sven
    • My husband and I would recommend Jessica to anyone searching for a home in New Jersey - she deserves 6 out of 5 stars. Her warmth and strong desire to help was apparent from our first phone conversation (I spoke with 3 agents on the phone and only chose to meet with Jessica). She is understanding, respectful of your time as a prospective homebuyer, extremely knowledgable of the area, and candid. As first-time homebuyers, my husband and I had a very limited knowledge of the buying process. Jessica took the time to explain every detail - advising us to put our best foot forward and to add personal touches to our offer which strengthened our position. Jessica has her client's best interest in mind - she did not hesitate to push to ensure we were satisfied, even when she met resistance. She has a stellar reputation and is connected with outstanding lenders, lawyers, inspectors, and others who helped us along the way. We would 100% work with her again!

      - Sarah A.
    • My husband and I have working with various real estate agents in the past years and none have been more professional and knowledgeable then Jessica Keefe. She truly helped us every step of the way in finding our new home, securing it, and figuring out our options with our existing home. She really went the extra mile for us and asked questions we would not have thought to. I have recommended her and will continue to recommend her to my friends and family now in the process of selling/purchasing a home.

      - Vanessa F.
    • We worked with Jessica to find our home in 2014. Working with her was a very positive experience. The market we purchased in is a rather competitive one and she was extremely helpful and knowledgeable throughout the entire process. It took nearly a year of looking for us to find our home and she was with us every step of the way. She really got to know us and exactly what we were looking for - to the point that if we saw a listing for a house we though we might like, she would scout it out first and tell us if she thought we would truly love it, and if it was truly worth the long drive from Brooklyn. Having someone who listened to us and totally understood what we were looking for saved us so much time and so many extra trips. As first time home buyers, we had no idea of how lengthy and complex the loan process could be. Jessica was great! She helped us through the entire process and was always able and quick to answer our many questions during what was a pretty daunting process for us. Additionally, she has a great deal of knowledge concerning older homes and the numerous details to be aware of when purchasing one - such as old oil tanks, knob and tube wiring and asbestos, etc. Even after we moved in, Jessica continued to work with us. She provided lists of good, reputable contractors and repair services, which was particularly helpful since we were new to the neighborhood. The great thing about Jessica is the transition didn't need the moment we got the keys to our house. Even a year later, if we have a question about our home or contractors, etc. Jessica is still just as helpful and quick to respond.Jessica was absolutely wonderful to work with and we would highly recommend her!

      - Stephanie
    • My husband and I are thrilled with the results we received from all of Jessica's hard work in selling our house. Jessica knows the market and knows what buyers are looking for. When we thought our house was sale ready, Jessica made a couple of key recommendations which we acted on which significantly increased the value of our home. Jessica's attention to detail throughout the process was impressive. She is very hands on, always available and ready to help and the consummate professional. We welcome the opportunity to work with her again.

      - Rich
    • Jessica was referred to us by friends who were very satisfied with their home buying experience. And so were we! Jessica was wonderful to work with, very responsive, professional, and knowledgeable. She helped us focus our sights realistically within our budget and did not lead us astray. Ultimately we got our dream house and are very happy there.

      - Awregar
    • Jessica is one of the best brokers my husband and I have ever used. She represented us on the sale of an investment property that needed a lot of repairs. Although it was a relatively small transaction in her portfolio, Jessica was very committed to the sale. She give us great advice on the work to do prior to the sale, arranged for the contractors and helped oversee the process. She was very resourceful and a pleasure to work with. She even arranged for flower pots to be placed in front of the property to improve its appearance. Without hesitation, we would strongly recommend Jessica as a broker.

      - S. Byoss
    • Jessica Keefe is the most knowledgeable realtor I ever met. She sold our home in NJ from the Open House. She has several sterling qualities. She is trustworthy, very responsible, enthusiastic, hardworking and has a great deal of integrity. Ms. Keefe is most creative and decorative. She knows how to showcase a home, paying great attention to the smallest detail. Her work is meticulous. Jessica Keefe is a first-rate realtor. We were completely satisfied with her and recommend her with complete confidence.

      - Byrd
    • We've known Jessica for years. When it came time for us to move we knew she would be our first choice for listing our house. She was thorough and meticulous in all aspects of the sale. She helped with staging and details down to what flowers to put in the flower boxes. She helped us pick the best time to sell and we were fortunate to get multiple bids that were all well above our asking price. Negotiations were smooth and uneventful all the way through closing. I would highly recommend Jessica for anyone looking to buy or sell in the Montclair area.

      - Ken C.
    • I had to rate Jessica as five stars- she really is a five star agent. It is safe to say I have seen Jessica in action - buying one home and selling two for us. My husband and I were first time home buyers and were not sure we wanted an agent - we had no idea how the whole thing worked. As a testament to my husband's dumb luck he called Jessica because of an interesting looking house she had listed. She walked us through the home buying processes step by step. She showed us countless houses (I lost count after 25). When we finally found one we liked she was exactly what you would want - once the bid was accepted she made demands on our behalf I would not have thought of. When our first home buy fell though she kept at with us - she was the one who found the house we now call home. Jessica called us and told us we HAD to see it, she was sure it was THE ONE. She even presented the bid in person to make sure we got the house. Not only did she help us to buy a home but helped my mother-in-law sell her house (mom moved in to our two family with us). Jessica was very honest with mom on what the house was worth and how to price it to sell. We got more than our asking. When my husband's aunt passed away and we needed to sell her house we know who to call. Again Jessica did the research told us what the house was worth. Again we sold the house for more than the asking price. Jessica was not just our realtor she is a friend now. If we ever decide to buy or sell another property she is the only person I would consider calling

      - Elizabeth
    • Jessica was incredibly helpful in the process of selling our house. She gave us honest feedback about what needed to be fixed/updated before putting our house on the market; she made the staging process easy, swift, and even fun; she guided us smartly on the offers that came in; and negotiated well in our favor. I would definitely use Jessica again and I recommend her highly!

      - Laura
    • I worked with Jessica first on a rental house in Millburn, NJ and eventually on the purchase of a home in Montclair NJ. She was fasntatic and we were not an easy client due to our situation. I was in the process of moving back to the US after several years abroad. She was patient enough to show me many option even though she knew we were not ready to close on a deal until later. Eventually, she even looked at a rental on our behalf because we were not in the US to visit. She did a great job of helping us secure a nice place even while we were still abroad. 6 Months later, we also used her to purchase a home in Montclair. The market was extremely competitve and people were overbidding by more than 70K. Again she was extremely patient, knowledgable and helped us prepare a successful bid for a house we love. Jessica is extremely accomodating, very knowledgable, professional and very easy to get along with. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a home especially in Montclair and surrounding reas. She knows everything we need to know about the town, and will find out anything else you can ask.

      - Camilo
    • A year before putting my house on the market, I began to work with Jessica. She gave valuable advice on how to present my home. When I finally did decide to sell, she worked worked hard to market it professionally. While it was being shown, we were in touch constantly. Jessica helped me price my house appropriately in the current market, and it sold in two weeks. Throughout the contract and sale, she was available to help in any way she could. Working with Jessica was probably the least stressful part of a very stressful process. I highly recommend Jessica Keefe!

      - Happy Seller
    • Jessica Keefe is a consummate professional,who sells your home and holds your hand the whole way through. She not only sold my house in a bad market,she also kept it from being a short sale and supported me throughout the whole procedure. Step by step she was there when I was feeling so alone and unsure of what was next. It felt like a true miracle how my house sold! I believe the sale of my house wouldn't of happened without Jessica's determination and drive. Jessica recommend my lawyer and also got involved with my bank, which held my mortgage and were impossible to deal with, she called the bank constanly to get the answers we needed. She not only helped me through this emotional process, she also was there for the people who were buying my house. Her voice alone is comforting and reassuring that everything is going to workout. She is incredible realtor and a smart woman and friend. I do and will continue to recommend Jessica Keefe and also will share my story and experience that I had working with Jessica.

      - Maplewood Home Seller
    • Jessica Keefe is an amazing agent who developed a sales strategy for my home that yielded well above asking price and far beyond my wildest expectations. She has impressive knowledge of the market, is well connected and very invested in the community. Jessica is also a great communicator; I was informed at every turn. Selling your home can be upsetting but Jessica made the whole experience as smooth as it possibly could be. I really cannot recommend Jessica highly enough.

      - Montclair Buyer & Seller
    • Jessica Keefe is a top rate and thorough professional. I have used Jessica to both purchase and sell my home. From start to finish Jessica handled all matters with complete professionalism and stead fast integrity. I have enthusiastically recommended Jessica to friends and colleagues who were all very impressed with the whole package. Jessica Keefe is top notch on all levels!

      - Argenta
    • Jessica represented us very well in the sale of our house - in fact, I do not believe that the sale would have been completed without her! She truly listened to our priorities and made things happen. We highly recommend Jessica, and would definitely work with her again!

      - Belleville Home Seller