Are you Nickie?
Claim Your Profile
Nickie O'toole Real Estate Agent at Nickie Otoole Realty Llc

Nickie O'toole

Real Estate Agent at
Nickie Otoole Realty Llc

Get introduced

Is Nickie the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Nickie's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Nickie sells properties fast - selling more than 56% quicker than the average Ansonia agent.
Nickie is a SFH expert - working with over 67% more single family homes than the average Ansonia agent.
Nickie has great Condo experience - having sold 38 more condos than the average agent.

More about Nickie O'toole

After more than a decade as an agent and Associate Broker for Action Realty Bob Pizzi, I have branched on to continue bringing my hard work and dedicated services to clients in my own brokerage. I have excelled in selling my listings and finding the best homes for my clients not only during the best of the times but also during the worst of times. I am one of the most consistent producers in my service areas. I take the time to understand the real marketability of your home. I work from the basement up to the roof to insure there are no surprises late in the process for buyers and sellers alike. Clients know me for my straightforward honesty and my knowledge of home construction, mechanicals and maintenance. Value determines how timely a home may sell and value determines how smoothly the buyer can execute a commitment. Value is also what I bring to my clients through my hard work from first contact to closings. Less interest, more money saved. I look forward to bringing Value to you both buyers and sellers.
License Number


Nickie O'toole's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Nickie O'toole

  • Nickie listed and sold my home

      She’s great but a bit sneaky.

    • Nickie helped me buy a home

        Nicky was very hard to work with. She called me one day and insisted I call a number for the UI disconnect which turned out to be a scammer wanting money from me and I had to go to my local police to report the incident. She would not always tell me when people were coming to look at my home . I would come home and either my front door was wide open not locked or things would be moved and out of place. I was scheduled to have a home inspection left the house only to find out when the inspection was to be done that it had been cancelled. It took Nickie weeks to post my home on the market missing good summer time weeks to sell it and or buy a better condo. She would meet me for important contracts in a McDonalds parking lot. I had to find my own condo and when I would try to put a bid in a little lower than asking price she would either not put the bid in or if I insisted on going lower for the condo I did get she took off the flooring and that cost me over 3 thousand dollars. I had to have the condo painted I did buy due to the lady being a smoker and it was a bad paint job I paid three thousand dollars for and when I contacted her the day before the closing she never contacted me back and I had also observed a mouse sticking it's end out of the condo unit ac plug hole. This has turned into quite a problem. She never arranged for a final walk through on the condo and never told me the condo association had low reserves and were in need of roofs and a new driveway.

        Show More
      • Nickie listed and sold my home

          Nickie was our listing agent when we sold our first home 17 years ago and our second home which we sold this year. She is very knowledgeable and gave us expert advice, allowing us to sell at our house at the price we were asking. She was always available when we had questions or concerns. We would definitely recommend Nickie O’Toole!