Randi Bennett Real Estate Agent at RE/MAX NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTIES

Randi Bennett

Real Estate Agent at

Currently accepting new clients

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Investment Properties
  • Relocations
  • New Construction
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist

Is Randi the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Randi's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Randi sells properties fast - selling more than 64% quicker than the average Boonton agent.
Randi also has Townhome expertise - working with over 19 more townhomes than the average agent.
Randi is a SFH expert - working with over 82% more single family homes than the average Boonton agent.

Randi's Transactions

  • Single Family Home
    4 bed / 3 bath
  • 3 Van Ness Dr
    Single Family Home
    4 bed / 4 bath
  • 44 Puddingstone Dr
    Single Family Home
    4 bed / 4 bath
  • 249 Robertson Way
    Lincoln Park
    2 bed / 2 bath
  • 36 Sherborne St
    Franklin Township
    Single Family Home
    2 bed / 2 bath
  • 24 Ryan Ln
    Lincoln Park
    2 bed / 2 bath
  • Single Family Home
    3 bed / 3 bath

More about Randi Bennett

Randi Bennett and Tracy Warsaw - The Power of a Pair - clients have access to two top agents. We listen to what our clients needs are and then we brainstorm to find ways to achieve their goal. Having two top agents looking out for you prevents any unnecessary complications and can give you peace of mind. By keeping her finger on the pulse of the latest trends of the Northern New Jersey real estate market, Randi Bennett is able to offer her clients top-notch guidance from start to finish. She ensures the entire process is seamless, efficient and rewarding. With over 14 years in the real estate industry, Randi saves her clients both time and money with appropriate decision making skills, expert guidance, personalized solutions based on her vast knowledge of the markets and powerful negotiation tactics. She treats her clients' needs as her own when she searches for the perfect ...
Show More
Other Certifications

Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES)


NJ Realtors® Distinguished Sales Club, Re/Max Chairman's Club and Platinum Club Award, Re/Max Hall of Fame, Circle of Excellence - 14 years, Five Star Real Estate Agent Award as seen in NJ Monthly for 10 consecutive years

License Number

HLAI 262348

Randi Bennett's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Randi Bennett

    • Randi is a highly regarded realtor and justly so. She goes above and beyond for her clients in providing advice on preparing a house to be sold, updates on the current state of your relevant housing market, and just generally ensuring the client understands what's happening with her house. You can definitely count on Randi as a reliable, honest, and empathetic realtor, which is why I would recommend her wholeheartedly.

      - sonyaching, Pine Brook, NJ
    • Working with Randi is amazing. Plain and simple. We both sold our last house and bought a new one with Randi, and things could not have gone any smoother. With Randi we always felt taken care of (no matter the price point). My husband and I had some poor real estate experiences in the past, and Randi put all our fears to rest. We highly recommend Randi to anyone looking to either buy and/or sell real estate. Never did we feel like Randi talked down to us, lectured us, or pressured us into anything. Randi encouraged us to continue our search until we were happy, which now we most certainly are! Thank you Randi!

      - Thomas Skomial, Pine Brook, NJ
    • Randi was extremely helpful throughout the entire process. When we needed something done at the home she was there to meet someone or was able to recommend someone in the trade. This was so helpful as I live out of state. I would definitely recommend Randi Bennett and would use her services again.

      - daledogs, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy was wonderful! We had casually looked at homes and were living in our townhome. We met her at an open house and she took it from there. She sold our townhome for over asking in less than a week . We found our perfect house ! It was not an easy closing due to septic issues but Tracy was there every step of the way ! She went above and beyond ... answering many many emails and phone calls ! We closed the exact day we had anticipated which was nothing short of a miracle. Thank you Tracy. I would highly highly recommend her.

      - RachelSenesky3, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi are two professionals who know their business. From listing my house ensuring that the list price was comparable to similar homes in my area to guiding me through the process, I felt very comfortable with their expertise. My house sold in only a few weeks and my transition to my new home went smoothly. I highly recommend these two women. Thank you Tracy and Randi!

      - suecoxg, Pompton Plains, NJ
    • They are great. They did not waist our time. Set the house for the right price for good traffic and moved it fast. I have sold and purchased an number of homes and these ladies are great. Thank you Troy

      - coachtroy2953, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi are both excellent real-estate agents and I highly recommend them to anyone in search of a new home! As first time home buyers, my husband and I were overwhelmed with the process. From the beginning of our search, Tracy sent us continuous listings with our budget until we finally found our dream home. She and Randi were extremely accommodating and flexible when scheduling times to view potential homes. Every single encounter with Tracy and Randi was extremely professional yet pleasant. Not only did they work tirelessly to help us find our ideal house, but offered support throughout the entire home buying process. From negotiating concessions to offering names of local home improvement professionals, Tracy and Randi truly helped us feel at ease during what may have been an otherwise daunting process. They also shared endless knowledge of Montville, helping us fall in love with the town that we now call our home. We are so grateful to have worked with Tracy and Randi, and highly recommend them to anyone looking for their dream home!

      - Pine Brook, NJ
    • These women are professional in every way. They quickly and expertly analyzed my local market, made suggestions that would make my house more appealing to buyers and helped me set a price that would attract the most qualified buyers. Their photos, descriptions, and online presentation made the most of what my home had to offer. They truly became my partners during this process. My home was listed at the start of Covid 19 and I was really concerned about people visiting. After a virtual tour of my house, only the most qualified and interested parties were invited in, always observing guidelines. Net result was three bids within the first few days, and we closed this morning at the price I was hoping for. These women get the job done. Happy to recommend.

      - Don Osur, Wayne, NJ
    • Tracy is very professional she took time to listen to what we were looking for. We liked that we did not feel any pressure at all while we were looking. Very helpful in giving us advise on different things.

      - Marie Fortaleza-Rojo, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi were great to work with. They are very knowledgeable and also very responsive to our needs. Tracy helped us buy our first home and just helped us sell it and buy a new home.

      - danag785, Towaco, NJ
    • When it comes to realtors, there is no one better than Tracy! This is our 4th transaction together and she has made each one easy, smooth and fun. Tracy is incredibly organized, knowledgeable and available. She is on top of every detail and makes her clients feel safe and assured. The highest recommendation for the best there is!

      - aliciacepstein, Wayne, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy were very upfront with their views on our house and they were right. We received several offers and were very happy with the results We would highly recommend and have already done so.

      - kathywhiteman0, Montville, NJ
    • Randi advised us against costly repairs and cosmetic work, explaining that the lack of parking would limit our sale price to the point that painting, etc. would not be cost-effective. Then she brought in a photographer to show all the best features of our little old house. When offers came in, she negotiated the best price.

      - Bloomfield, NJ
    • We had a great experience working with Randi & Tracy. We couldnt believe how responsive they were to all of our requests and questions, and they knew far more than we ever hoped to about the process.

      - Montville, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy took the time to evaluate the value of our home, price it well for the market and get the job done. They were very professional, effective and a pleasure to work with.

      - bikegirl32, Montville, NJ
    • Wonderful experience all around. Randi and Tracy helped us find a home in a 55+ community and then sold our home with excellent results. We listened to their pricing strategy, and sure enough we had 3 offers within one week of listing our home. Randi and Tracy made sure everything went smoothly, inspections, deposit money, and certificate of occupancy were all done on time. Nothing was missed due to their ability to stay on top of everything related to our purchase and sale. We trusted them right from the start, they made us feel comfortable and we were expertly guided throughout the process. We would highly recommend this team to anyone!

      - genwa, Wayne, NJ
    • Great experience! They new exactly what my familys needs were and did not try to sell us anything different. They spent the time to find the perfect home for our family!

      - bethd09, Montville, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy were very helpful in both the purchase of our new home and the selling of our old home. We initially met Randi as she was the listing realtor of the house we were interested in. She was instrumental in having the owners quickly accept our offer as they were planning an open house later that week. We later were introduced to Tracy who facilitated the plan for selling our old house. To be honest, the selling of the house did not go as smoothly as purchasing due to outside factors but both Randi and Tracy worked hard for us by having multiple open houses and keeping us informed as sellers as to traffic our listing was seeing. They were constantly in touch with us giving us updates and answered any questions we might have. We appreciate the great work they have done and would recommend them to anyone.

      - pierrekew, Pine Brook, NJ
    • It was a pleasure working with Randi and Tracy. They were both professional and pleasant, from beginning to end of our real estate transaction. They stayed on top of all aspects of the process, and kept in touch with important details. We would be happy to use them again for any of our real estate needs in the area.

      - MONTIMAXX, Towaco, NJ
    • Tracy was a great broker. She was professional and knows the marketplace. She was able to negotiate a great price and close the deal very quickly. I highly recommend her

      - David Kastin, Montville, NJ
    • Randi me Tracy made our first-time buying process great! They are highly knowledgeable and their customer service is unmatched! Theyre always available when you have a question, and they truly make you feel like theyll do their absolute best to get you into your dream home. We absolutely loved working with them!

      - dibiancoe, Towaco, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy make a great team and it was a pleasure to work with them. They are professional, great communicators, dedicated and experienced. The moment you meet them you will know and feel for yourself that they will get your house sold.

      - thomasjheinz531, Montville, NJ
    • These two ladies are the best. They sold our condo in 8 days and at less than 1/2% below asking. Their communications skills are impeccable. They return calls and texts immediately. They have an extensive list of reliable vendors that we needed to make our move as easy as possible. Their team approach is unique and guarantees that all bases are covered and their customers are taken care of. We strongly recommend them if you are thinking fo buying or selling.

      - mginzie5, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy was always prompt in her response. She has thorough knowledge of the market and references provided by her were also reliable & prompt to work with.

      - Kalpa Rupesh, Lake Hiawatha, NJ
    • Working with Randi & Tracy in selling our home was a wonderful experience. They guided us and and made a life changing decision easy for us. They took much of the stress in selling our home away by keeping in close communication with us so we were able to make decisions that I believe sold our home quickly. Have 2 brokers working for you is definitely a plus.

      - bsf1259, Towaco, NJ
    • It was a pleasure working with both Tracy and Randi for my first home purchase. Having two agents both working towards the same goal really yielded quick responses which is very important in this competitive housing market. Once I found a house I liked, they gave great advise on how much to offer which in the end saved me money and got me under contract. They then recommended a great lender who was able to close in ~30 days. Would highly recommend.

      - Montville, NJ
    • I had the opportunity to work with both Randi and Tracy while searching for a new home in Towaco. Both made it very easy to look at homes and as we found the right home, they walked us through the buying process start to finish. The process went really smooth. I would definitely work with both Randi and Tracy again.

      - chrisjstols5, Towaco, NJ
    • Very knowledgable and were able to be supportive throughout the process of selling our home. Response time to any questions was very timely! My husband and I would use Randi and Tracy again!

      - cooann, West Orange, NJ
    • Tracy and Randy were very helpful and patient with the whole process. They gave me great advice about the property and they provided contacts for the whole closing process also.

      - Pallavi Shende, Montville, NJ
    • Randi is very professional, attentive to detail and a pleasure to work with. Randi responded very quickly to every email, text and phone call, and was able to work around our busy schedules. She is extremely professional and dedicated to her job. We are so happy in our new home!! I would highly recommend Randi! Thank you, Jessica & Phil

      - jessielj7, Cedar Grove, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi helped with both my long search for the perfect house within very specific parameters and the unbelievable quick sale of my home for TOP dollar. Their patience, advice, more patience and knowledge made everything turn out as it did which was PERFECT!!!

      - sueapple973, Montville, NJ
    • We had been looking for a house in Montville for a long time. We had specific needs and were not ready to compromise on some of our requirements. For personal reasons, we also had a pause in our search. Tracy and Randi accommodated are needs very well. They were responsive to our questions and pro-active in helping us find our dream house. Even though we took a long time to decide, we never felt pressured during the process. We enjoyed working with them and really love the house we purchased! They are a great team and have good knowledge of the area.

      - Montville, NJ
    • I would gladly recommend these professionals..... They are thorough and made the whole process as enjoyable as can be!!!!!!! You can never ever go wrong with this team. From pricing to marketing to preparation for showing they were right on the money.

      - dr depietro1, Towaco, NJ
    • They have provided very professional service and very easy to work with. We have sold our house in 2 days over the asking price. Thank you both Randi & Tracy.

      - mehmeto, Montville, NJ
    • My 86 year old mom always thought she would live out her years in her beautiful nyc apartment, but when the coop board voted to sell the building and forced her out, we decided to move her closer to us in New Jersey. Thank god I called Randi Bennett ! She worked tirelessly and patiently until we found the perfect two bedroom condo in the middle of a busy town center so Mom would feel right at home! I told her I needed no stairs, shower in the master bath, doorman building, close to elevator.... this list was endless! Nothing was an effort for Randi.. she showed up at all hours with a warm comforting smile and the confidence and experience that would have mom settled in no time!! Thank you Randi! I am SO grateful!!

      - debbie48121, Short Hills, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy are true professionals. They were extremely helpful from beginning to end and took a lot of the stress out of a potentially stressful process. They were both personal, professional, and very responsive, as well as genuinely very nice people. We highly recommend their services. They were a pleasure to work with!

      - fiedmek, Montville, NJ
    • Do not trust your home sale to just anyone. Randi and Tracy are the team you need to get the job done. They are knowledgeable, fun to work with and tough negotiators.

      - bjaurori, Montville, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy were incredible to work with. They were timely, patient and extremely insightful. They took my opinions into consideration while providing key, professional expertise. They are highly recommended and have a client for life from my perspective. Thank you ladies!!

      - ldika82, Montville, NJ
    • Highly recommend Randi. She helped us get out of NYC and into Morris county during the pandemic.. Shes knowledgeable and always available. She showed us many homes and was extremely helpful and kind

      - Davenjnyc, Montville, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy are an absolute pleasure to work with. They are courteous, professional and care about their clients. If I text or email them they respond immediately. I have always found whenever I have a question they always have a terrific response.

      - richem3, West Orange, NJ
    • Randi and Tracy were professional and knowledgeable and worked very hard to get our house sold. The photography and video quality was excellent and helped to get potential buyers looking at our home. We would highly recommend them to seller and buyers.

      - spechfamily, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi were truly amazing to deal with on both the sale of our house and the purchase of our new home! They were one step ahead of us at every turn. Tracy and Randi are extremely knowledgeable, decisive, and always available. Their services are best in class in every way!

      - etlusty9, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy was truly excellent and everything you wanted in a buyers agent. We met her at a house showing before we had a buyers agent and immediately felt comfortable. She showed us lots of houses, based on our selections from Zillow, across many towns until we finally came across the house for us. Then her work truly began. She was helpful in moving the process along quickly, worked with the sellers agent and provided amazing insight & advice throughout. Youll be waiting a long time to find yourself a better agent.

      - bouncy_castle, Montville, NJ
    • Tracy and Randi were wonderful to work with, they made the process as easy as possible. They were knowledgeable, professional and provided the perfect marketing to get our house sold. They both brought unique strengths to the process, skills not easily possessed by a single agent. They provided guidance and had the patience to see a difficult transaction through from start to finish. I would not hesitate to recommend them, in fact I even recommended them to my mother-in-law. If you're looking for top notch realtors in the area, you'd be hard pressed to find better than Randi and Tracy!!

      - Stephen Walker, Pine Brook, NJ
    • The team of Tracy and Randi did an outstanding job from start to finish. They did a market analysis, advised me on how to present my home, and generated lots of interest resulting in an offer at the asking price within a few days. Their marketing was incredible! From aerial videos to professional photographs, the entire property looked great. Finally, they were in contact with me throughout the selling process and responded quickly to any questions or concerns. Its my pleasure to recommend this dynamic duo!

      - aimeebrash, Wayne, NJ
    • Randi always had fast response times and was extremely helpful! She was very pleasant to work with and I would work with her again. Thanks again~! I would recommend anyone else work with her.

      - bajisci, Montville, NJ
    • STANDARD OF EXCELLENCE. If I could allocate more stars I would. My experience with the team of Randi and Tracy was outstanding. Particularly in a volatile and interesting real estate market, Randi and Tracy excel in the following: 1) Communication and responsiveness: They work seamlessly together and explain details effectively and in an organized manner. 2) Knowledge and Expertise: They truly UNDERSTAND this industry and have the ability to provide excellent counsel. 3) General Personality: This is so important! Agents must deal with a number of different parties, other agents, buyers, sellers, attorneys, the list goes on. Working with them was a total pleasure, and their professional and personal qualities will serve you well!

      - suzyc128, Chester, NJ
    • We finally closed on our Condo after a Two year long journey and couldn't have done it without Tracy from day one, Tracy made us feel like we were her only clients - always providing expert, honest, and timely advice. Tracy showed us countless Condos, negotiated a fair deal, and helped us finally close on a Condo that "checked" all our boxes. We lived in our home for 52 years and Tracy knows the home buying process can be emotional and scary for both buyer and seller; however, she was always there, without judgement. Tracy told us from the beginning that the right place was out there - and she helped to make that happen. We highly recommend Tracy Warsaw for any of your real estate needs.

      - joel0692, Wayne, NJ
    • Working with Randi and Tracy was great. The communication was top-notch. Whenever I had a question or needed help, their response was quick. They would always find a solution or answer that was necessary and really cared about what I wanted and needed. They were super friendly and super easy to work with. Highly recommend!

      - jjfish66, Montville, NJ
    • After finally deciding to sell our home,I called the real estate team of Randy and Tracy at Re Max Realty. Both Randy and Tracy came to my home did a analysis as to what we should list the home for. We wound up listing with them as a result of the expertise they showed when discussing the sale of our home. They scheduled a open house and we sold in three days with multiple bids over our asking price. If you decide to sell the team of Randy and Tracy will get it done for you. Thanks Randy and Tracy

      - htapple26harvey, Montville, NJ