Sara Dreyer Real Estate Agent at Keller Williams Prestige Realty

Sara Dreyer

Real Estate Agent at
Keller Williams Prestige Realty

Currently accepting new clients

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Farm Property
  • Relocations
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Probate
  • New Construction
  • Waterfront Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist
  • Land Specialist
  • Horse Properties

Is Sara the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Sara's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Sara sells properties fast - selling more than 48% quicker than the average Richfield agent.
Sara gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Richfield agent by 14%.
Sara is a SFH expert - working with over 69% more single family homes than the average Richfield agent.

Sara's Transactions

  • Menomonee Falls, WI
    Single Family Home
  • Milwaukee, WI
    Single Family Home
  • Hartford, WI
    Single Family Home
  • Menomonee Falls, WI
    Single Family Home
  • Milwaukee, WI
    Multi Family
  • Germantown, WI
    Single Family Home
  • Brookfield, WI
    Single Family Home

More about Sara Dreyer

With integrity, expertise and hard work, The SOLD BY SARA Team is a Total Real Estate Resource that provides exceptional customer-focused results for all buyers and sellers. Our buyers and sellers enjoy a successful, personalized real estate experience from the most friendly, patient and highly skilled real estate team in Wisconsin; while we collectively contribute to our local communities, making them a better place to live. The Sold By Sara Team has been helping families in the metro Milwaukee area move since 1994 and is one of the most successful teams in the Midwest. We have helped over 2,000 happy families move. Averaging a home sold every 3 days we specialize in residential real estate and have developed a unique and highly effective marketing program. Sara's specialized Team approach ensures sellers and buyers true representation and excellent service. The Team consists of ...
Show More


Top Negotiator 2021


Wichita State University Graduate, Wichita State University, University of North Texas

Other Certifications

Certified Negotiation Expert, Certified Investor Agent Specialist (CIAS)


Milwaukee Magazine 5-Star Realtor, RE/MAX Lifetime Acheivement Award , Top 1% in Wisconsin, 2015-17 Top 5 REMAX TEAM in Metro MKE, Best of Homelight TOP SELLER'S AWARD 2018, Best of Homelight TOP "SELLS FOR MORE" Agent 2018, Best of HomeLight TOP BUYER'S AGENT 2018

License Number


Sara Dreyer's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Sara Dreyer

  • Sara listed and sold my home

      Sara and her team was exceptional. They delivered results that exceeded my expectations. I would definitely use their services in the future.

    • Sara is very upfront and honest throughout the entire process of selling your home. She likes to make sure everything is in place, on target and ready to go when your home is listed. Sara and her team were easy to reach for questions, and they had solutions/answers for us when we needed them. By listening to Sara's suggestions, it was a quick sell for us. I would highly recommend Sara and her team.

      - Chris Hood
    • Sara Dreyer and her team are very competent and knowledgeable about the ever changing real estate market. They are very friendly and make themselves available.

      - Dave Baker
    • Our home had an offer on it. Our agent showed us anyways just so we could get an idea of what we liked/disliked. We fell in love with it. We were lucky enough to end up getting it. We are convinced he made it possible as another agent would have excluded it from our search. The whole process from hunting to closing was done very professionally. We saw nearly every house we asked to see and we were always provided with extensive information on each listing prior to viewing it. He also made the effort to have an answer for every question we came up with along the way. This is our first home purchase and we will recommend the Sold By Sara team to anyone every time.

      - Andrew Stainbeck
    • On the ball all the time. Always available to answer questions. Walked us through the entire process. I would recommend her and her team to anyone. Sara and her buyer agent, Justin Voisin, are a great combination when listing your current home and buying another.

      - Matt Burkart
    • Sara is a consummate professional. Of the 3 agents we spoke with when we started looking for an agent, Sara was the only one that brought comps for 4 bedroom homes only (since we were selling a 4 bedroom house) to validate her price suggestion. The other 2 agents brought mostly 3 bedroom comps. Consequently they were going to list our house at maybe $165K max and Sara suggested $189K. The house sold in 1 day for a little over Sara's asking price. We were impressed!Sara and her team (never more than a phone call away) kept us informed all the way through to the closing. Each step the team kept us informed and immediately handled any of our concerns or questions. Sara and her team were very knowledgeable, easy to talk with and never talked down to us. She knows how the property should look to sell. We organized the house just like she suggested and it worked. To say we are happy with Sara and her team is an understatement. We couldn't be happier with how we were treated and especially the outcome!

      - Al Strauss
    • Very responsive, professional and was very impressed with her marketing plan. She answered questions very concisely and walked us thru the whole selling process which was helpful since some laws/regulations had changed since the last time we had gone thru this. Would definitely work with her again and have already referred her to others.

      - Wendy Snedaker
    • Sara and Sold By Sar a Team including Catherine were awesome to work with. Sara had a great presentation. Her marketing was phenomenal and very impressive. I thoroughly enjoyed working with the team. Very quick with responses when I had a question. Scheduled any repairs needed on my house. It went smooth and Sara always had my best interest at heart. I truly loved working with her and her knowledge of the area was awesome. Catherine was great to work with. She was always there for me and had our best interest at heart. I would recommend the team highly they are truly great Real Estate team. Thanks Sold By Sara Team.

      - Sheila Wilson
    • Sara and Justin sat down with me and walked me through the entire process before I signed the paperwork. There was a buyer immediately interested, and before a SALE sign went up, the house was sold. All the paperwork associated with a house sale was easy to complete via their electronic signature system and email correspondence. Her staff quickly responded to my inquiries. In addition, I was able to pre-sign all the final closing papers, which was greatly appreciated! Thanks Sara and Team!

      - Steve Koch
    • Sara was incredibly helpful in guiding us through our first home-selling experience. At our first meeting she came prepared with valuable information about the other homes in the area so we could make an informed decision about what to list our house for. She was always available to answer our questions and really helped us feel at ease about the entire process. With her help, we accepted an offer within 24 hours of listing our house and closed within 45 days.

      - Allie Reeme
    • Sara and her team were very helpful in selling my home. I was able to close in 60 days. Sara was knowledgeable about the area and was very good at presenting options and answering questions. If Sara was unavailable one of her team members responded to my inquiry in a short period of time. Sara and her team are very professional. I felt they had my best interest in mind. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Sara to a friend looking to buy or sell a home.

      - Kelly Burt
    • GREAT! Always responsive, keeps your interest and budget in mind. Looking to make her clients happy is number 1 and she'll go above and beyond to do so. I would highly recommend her to all my friends and family!

      - Katy Paquette
    • Sara and her team were very knowledgeable and extremely helpful. The advice provided for staging my home was so helpful and really made an impact! Sara and her team were always available when I had questions and they were very organized with the checklists and timelines they provided. Sara made my first selling process easy!

      - Heidi Feurig
    • Sara did a fantastic job with us throughout all phases of the selling process. From the first day we sat down to discuss the selling/buying process to the last counter-offer/accepted offer, she was outstanding. Proactive communication and a very competent staff to assist.

      - Bryan Niketh
    • My husband and I were recommended Sara for buying/selling our home by another family member, who had a wonderful experience. Sara was very knowledgeable about the real estate process, the steps we needed to take to prepare our home for potential buyers, kept us updated as things moved along and helped us navigate the steps form beginning to end. Sara and her team were very friendly, available to answer any questions and were a delight to work with. Highly recommend.

      - Jaimie Mitchell
    • We had an excellent experience working with Sara Dreyer. She and her Re/Max team are true professionals. Every detail was taken care of in a timely manner and any question we had was answered quickly and thoroughly. Sara and her team were with us every step of the way through the home buying and selling process. Saras knowledge of the local and regional market in southeastern Wisconsin is spot on and helped us sell our home quickly. We highly recommend Sara Dreyer for any type of real estate transaction. She and her team certainly went above and beyond!

      - Brian Glaszcz
    • Sara (and the entire Sold by Sara Team) was a pleasure to work with. As a first time home buyer I've now learned experience is so key when buying a home, and it's incredibly beneficial to have someone who has many years of continued success under her belt. I'm so very thankful to have had someone like Sara to guide me through my first experience.

      - Rachael Glaszcz
    • She was knowledgeable, patient and friendly. She was always available to answer our questions. We loved the way she staged our home. We were very pleased to get very close to our asking price. Closing was simple.

      - Charles Corrao
    • Sara Dreyer and her team are amazing! Sara gave me tips on presenting my home in the best light, and I received 3 great offers within 2 days! Sara and her team were always right there to help with any questions I had, and explained every step of the process. Sara's assistant, Ashley Andrews, was instrumental in keeping me informed regularly, and is a great asset to the team as well.

      - Patti Satffeldt
    • Sara and her team are reliable, hardworking and very supportive. Sara is expert and has so much knowledge about how to market the house. She knew exactly what type of a potential buyer our house will have and what are the things to be done in order to get a good buyer. Her team have been very supportive , I was out of state and my family is still in the house while it's on the market and she always made sure her team gets back to me if I have questions , she works around my crazy schedule. She recommends people to do work that don't overcharge , I never had issue making a long distance business with her and you know what ? My house after being on the market for two days , yes for two days only two days open house it had a buyer and Sara did her best to get the that buyer and in a month we had it closed and sold By Sara . Thank you so much . Many can't believed how fast the house was sold.

      - Noralyn David
    • My wife and I were in the early stages of considering a home search when we came across one of Sara's listings. It was late in the evening on a Saturday night, but I thought... what the heck... I will call her anyways. Calling Sara that night ended up being one the best decisions we ever made! We didn't buy the house she was listing, nor did we even see it. But what we did do, was find one of the highest quality realtors in the area! Sara's performance was differentiated by the following: 1) She got to know us and our family. This meant a lot to us and Sara quickly demonstrated we weren't just another sale to her. She invested in our relationship and developed the trust we were looking for. 2) She was patient. We went house shopping with a five month old at the time... that alone... required a lot of patience! My wife and I had an idea of what we wanted, but it took us time to figure out exactly what we needed. Sara helped us figure that out. 3) She was honest. There were many times Sara could have told us what we wanted to hear. She didn't... she was honest with us. Throughout the entire process, Sara was always upfront and provided her professional opinion, regardless if it was what we wanted to hear. 4) She was professional. Sara always had our best interest in mind. She always kept us up to speed with next steps. She demonstrated her expertise in many, many ways. For example, she identified errors in the title company's closing documents which impacted the cash flows. Flash forward 7 months. We changed our course and rather than buying a home, we ended up building and Sara was with us every step of the way. We are so thankful for Sara and are so appreciative to have had the opportunity to work with her. Thank you Sara, from the bottom of our hearts!

      - Brandon Hilker
    • Sara Dreyer and the entire Remax/Sold by Sara team are fantastic. My husband and I were selling a property from out of state & I can't imagine partnering with a more capable team. From the first meeting to the closing Sara & team had our back. Sara has a list of contractor's and vendors that were incredible (competitive pricing, great work and willing to be on the job with little to no notice). Sara coached us on the market, helped with the staging & work we needed to do prior to listing & proved to be a shrewd & fair negotiator after we received offers and were preparing for closing. We were in competent hands! Can't say enough about Sara & Team! They NEVER missed a beat, kept in front of issues and made sure that we were moving forward quickly. I can honestly say I would not consider any other agency. They are simply the best!

      - Khris Schwoeppe
    • Sara and her team were always very responsive to any questions or request for information we had regarding the selling process for our home. Her knowledge of the local market was also very helpful in the process. We took advantage of the no charge "staging" service that Sara provided, which we feel was helpful in the sale of our house.

      - Fred Bartelt
    • Working with Sara and her team was a total joy. They were professional and personable at all times. I would highly recommend Sara and her team. The web site was beautifully done. We sold our home in record time. Thank you Sara and all who work on team Sara.

      - Pamela Anderson
    • This is the second time we have used the SOLD BY SARA team. Sara's team, including Justin, is attentive and listen to what you want in a house as a buyer, will answer your calls any time, and treat you like family not just another client. As a seller they provide realistic advice and know what it takes to sell your home. You will not regret using the SOLD BY SARA team!!

      - Susan Sawdey
    • Sara and her team made selling our house easy. With a short timeframe due to relocation and a chaotic household (new baby and 2 dogs), Sara and her team were amazing at helping us get the house shown and sold between nap times. Her knowledge of effective marketing channels, the local market and negotiation made everything painless and quick. We had multiple offers multiple times (because our first offer fell through due to lender issues). Sara and her team guided us the whole way! We are forever grateful!

      - Julie Burke
    • Sara and her team were amazing. We had a short selling window due to relocation and her team got everything done quickly and efficiently. Her team helped us watch over the house when we had moved away and took care of all the details. The app they use for showings is easy and whenever we had a question someone on her team was available to help. We HIGHLY recommend Sold by Sara to anyone in SE Wisconsin.

      - Chad Kleist
    • Sara is very knowledgeable in the real-estate market and has allot of expertise in the entire process. She is very detailed from start to finish. Communication is excellent and her team is also there to help and support during the process. Selling a home is a one chance opportunity. Knowing how to present the home as a package is where realtors fall short. Sara's team is there to coach and help with staging and photos. Nothing is missed.

      - Miro Jankovic
    • Home buying can be a very stressful time - especially for first time home buyers. The Sold by Sara Team kept me informed on everything all along the way. Meeting with my realtor at times that worked with my job really meant a lot to me. Thank you so much a great experience!

      - Dennis Carter
    • We cannot say enough about the Sold by Sara team in the sale of our home. We were able to get our asking price with the negotiating of Sara. She was very knowledgeable and accurate with the pricing of our home although initially I thought we may have been too high. The whole process went as smooth as it possibly could.

      - Bob Muselman
    • I cannot say enough great things about Sara! She is truly professional, reliable and knowledgeable. She brought in a stager and professional photographer that really made our home's pictures look incredible. Sara and team work extreme efficiently and their communication is incredible (we knew about every appointment, she worked with us through a much anticipated late night offer). We've worked with quite a few different agents in the different places we've lived/explored to live and no one even began to compare to Sara and her team. They provided beautiful flyers on our home, thorough listings on MLS and Zillow, voice recorded information on our home for anyone passing by, an app to confirm/decline/suggest new time for appointments and biweekly listing reports to let you know how you listing is doing. Even once our home had an offer, they ensure that the home still had flyers and was ready in case something were to happen. Through Sara's hard work (and a pretty great market), we sold our home to the first people to walk through it on the first day. We could not be more pleased. I would definitely recommend Sara's team to anyone!

      - Brittney Grieser
    • What a great team to work with could not be happier with there services. I will be working with them for all my future real estate needs. I would highly recommend them.

      - Mike Granato
    • Sara and her team are excellent at communication and very responsive. Having a team in the office made it very easy to get good turnaround on questions. I received clear explanations and good guidance during negotiations and through closing.

      - Gary Schmidt
    • Wow! It's been over 30 years since our last home sale and we didn't know what to expect. What a joy to have Sara and her team looking out for us at every turn.

      - Jim Angeli
    • We had a great experience with the Sold by Sara team, they really worked together to make sure that our needs were met. We looked at many properties in a variety of cities to find a location and community that best suits our family. Their experience truly showed in negotiations as our new home was in a multiple offer situation. The guidance afforded to us really lent itself to am overall great experience.

      - Christina Knivilla
    • Caring, understanding our needs. Responded quickly to many questions. Very professional. Excellent staff and very supportive. Lots of energy and dedication.

      - Linda Jacobsen
    • Sara and her team did an excellent job from start to finish. Sara is very familiar with the area and the properties. She made sure the showings went smoothly and she was quick to respond to any questions we had. Sara had good suggestions for staging the house and her team handled all the paperwork and the entire process was seamless. I would definitely recommend Sara and her team.

      - Jana Champion
    • With the baby number three due in only four months, we decided to list our home and look for a bigger house. In less than 48 hours we had two offers on our house over asking price! We got more money for our home than I ever thought possible. Sara has great marketing and house staging skills and really knows how to draw interest on a property. It took us a little longer to find a house we liked, but with Justin's help on the buying end of things, we are just currently settling into our new home before the holidays with only 8 weeks until baby's arrival. We had a great experience and highly recommend the Sara Dreyer team!

      - Melanie Ehrgott
    • Sara has helped me to sell two homes, a 5 acre property and my parents' house during the past 10 years. Sara is knowledgeable, professional and has a team and process that really works. I highly recommend Sara if you are buying or selling real estate in Southeastern Wisconsin!

      - Julie West
    • Sara worked with me to sell a home in New Berlin. I lived over 200 miles away and she was very responsive and active in the sale. She or one of her office team would check on the house to make sure all was ready for a showing. When a small repair was needed she found the repair person for us and set up the work, making sure someone was at the house to open the door for the repair service. I could not have asked for a better real estate person!

      - Sandy Hanke
    • Sara is the type of realtor a buyer or seller really needs. I would never use a "friend" or family for a real estate transaction. I want someone who is tenacious, respectful, efficient, professional, persuasive, and objective to the transaction while still remaining as a strong advocate for us. That is Sara. I have confidence in Sara and her team, and we have recommended Sara to others and will continue to do so.

      - Kyle Gulya
    • Sara and her team went the extra mile in selling our home. Since we were gone during a lot of the process, the team had extra jobs to get the house ready for showings that the homeowner usually does. Sara also contacted interested but undecided buyers when an offer was forthcoming so we ended up with 3 offers instead of one. What a wonderful dilemma. I highly recommend Sara and her team.

      - Gretchen Hudock
    • Sara was excellent and did everything possible to make the sale of our home go smoothly. She took time to understand our needs and was invaluable in the selection of our new home.

      - Phyllis Kemp
    • Sara and her team worked out great. Got the price we wanted and sold in 4 days. She sent out a "stager" before we listed to help us get our house looking as best it could.

      - Fred Regenfuss
    • Very easy and pleasurable to work with, very knowledgeable marketing skills, She and her associates were so quick to respond to any and all problems or questions that I had. When I had doubts, she gave me the assurance that it will sell. And it did!!

      - Carolyn Sammer
    • As first time buyers, we had a lot of questions involving the purchasing process. Sara's team was extremely knowledgeable, helpful, and courteous. The team was flexible with their time and accommodated our demanding work schedules. They were able to find a home that matched what we were looking for. We found our new home and are very confident about our decision! I recommend Sara's team every chance I get.

      - Jacob Peterson
    • I don't typically write reviews online but have to make an exception for Sara Team. Our experience with Sara's Team was outstanding! From the very first walk through of our house, the team was available for us. They gave us advice on how to get the house ready to sell. They were always responsive whenever i needed them and always kept us in the loop. They were always available for questions and discussions. we need to sell the house as soon as we can and they made happen like Magic and sold are house in less then a week. I would highly recommend the Sara and her team without hesitation :)

      - Savleen Chanana