Stacy Mcfadden Real Estate Agent at Signature Premier Properties

Stacy Mcfadden

Real Estate Agent at
Signature Premier Properties

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins


  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Investment Properties
  • Relocations
  • Probate
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist
  • First Time Home Buyer Specialist

Is Stacy the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Stacy's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Stacy is a SFH expert - working with over 86% more single family homes than the average North Babylon agent.
First-rate service. Made the entire process of selling my home almost effortless for me. Stacy found a buyer with an excellent offer in less than one week. She was extremely helpful with the closing p...

Stacy's Transactions

  • 410 Cedar Drive, Mattituck, NY 11952
    Single Family Home
    3 bed / 2 bath
  • 3127 Hewlett Ave, Merrick, NY 11566
    Single Family Home
    3 bed / 3.0 bath
  • 970 Village Lane, Mattituck, NY 11952
    Single Family Home
    4 bed / 2 bath
  • 52 Robinson Street, Shoreham, NY 11786
    Single Family Home
    3 bed / 3.0 bath
  • 8 Nicole Court, Bohemia, NY 11716
    Single Family Home
    4 bed / 3.0 bath
  • 16 Edward, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    Lake Ronkonkoma
    Single Family Home
    2 bed / 2.0 bath
  • 155 E 5th Street, Deer Park, NY 11729
    Deer Park
    Single Family Home
    3 bed / 1 bath

More about Stacy Mcfadden

Stacy L McFadden is a Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker in New York and is currently working with Signature Premier Properties in Babylon. When you work with me, you tap into the collective experience of the best, most experienced Realtors on Long Island. As a full time realtor with the Long Island Board of Realtors for over 10 years, I have been helping first time home buyers achieve the American dream and sellers get to the next phase of their lives. With tireless attention to the needs of my clients, my only goal is a successful transaction every time. The saying, "the apple does not fall far from the tree" applies directly to me as my mom is a realtor also. Like mother like daughter, I hail from a family dedicated to helping people. I believe strongly in continuing my education as well as offering state-of-the-art information and technology to my clients. Broker ...
Show More
Other Certifications

Associate Broker, Accredited Buyer Representative, Seller Representative Specialist, Short Sale Certified


#1 Agent in Babylon Office 2016, #1 Agent in Babylon Office 2017, #1 Agent in Babylon Office 2018, #1 Agent in Company in Units in 2017, #1 Agent in Babylon Office 2019

License Number


Stacy Mcfadden's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Stacy Mcfadden

  • Stacy listed and sold my home

      First-rate service. Made the entire process of selling my home almost effortless for me. Stacy found a buyer with an excellent offer in less than one week. She was extremely helpful with the closing process. A+

    • Stacy helped me buy a home

        Stacy was wonderful. She was extremely knowledgeable of the area and totally trustworthy. She was a great guide and help in what can be a tough and confusing process.

      • Stacy helped me buy a home

          Stacy is an amazing realtor and friend. She showed us a number of homes before finding our dream home. She was able to assist me with all my questions, AND keep the stressful situation (at times) calm. I would definitely recommend her for any real estate needs.

        • Stacy listed and sold my home

            Stacy is the absolute best!!

          • Stacy listed and sold my home

              Stacy is very knowledgeable and professional..easy smooth transaction with selling my home...

            • Stacy showed me homes

                Excellent !! Stacey is very sweet and caring. She is very knowledgeable about the business and has patience of a saint. She sold my sister's house , found my niece a home and sold my friend's home. She has become a dear friend. I would highly recommend Stacey for your real estate needs !!!

              • Stacy listed and sold my home

                  Stacy is wonderful. She came all the way from the South Shore of Suffolk to Commack, where I needed to find a home. And she found me a good home in a good neighborhood in a price that I could afford. She gave me tons of attention and time. She was really there for me. I was going through a divorce and was in a bad place mentally and she didn't let me down. In fact, she picked me up!

                • Stacy helped me buy a home

                    Stacy was great every step of the way and made our first home purchase a breeze and a wonderful experience! She was very knowledgeable and listened to all of our wishes and any questions or concerns. Stacy was easily reachable and was a pleasure to have as our realtor. We still have contact with her and for our next home purchase will be using her again.

                  • Stacy helped me buy a home

                      Stacy was relentless In helping locate our home. We lived in Texas and flew to New York several times. Each and every time she had appointments for homes within our budget and criteria ready to go. She is very knowledable on llocal areas, laws, and even accompanied us at closing.

                    • Stacy listed and sold my home

                        Stacy sold my home in 4 months. That's including closing! She's awesome. I recommend.

                      • To begin with this was a very short and the most happiest journey but the crux is to choose a real estate agent who sells your home with a minimum supervision for feedbacks etc and within a short frame of time. I conducted a lot of research and interviewed about 8 realtors to see who would be the best choice based on the investment they make into selling the property (time and effort, not necessarily financially) and how they promote their listings. Finally I have selected Stacy who works for Signature Premier Properties Team stood out as the best cause of their rankings are excellent (meaning people find listings on his site easily), their social media presence was strong, and I could tell they put a lot of work into their listings. And the most impressive work is the pictures. Excellent photography of your house 360( includes virtual tour as well) I spent about an hour with Stacy on the first day where she added the value in, providing objective data regarding how many homes they sell, how long their listings typically stay on the market, and providing tons of info on comps in the area. When we saw our listing we were blown away. Her hard work and knowledge of what it takes to sell a home really paid off - our listing looked amazing and knocked out the competition. Our house went under contract in couple weeks after we put it on the market at 1.4% under asking price. We accepted and stacy walked us through every step of the closing process. It couldn't have been a more pleasant experience. I've recommended the Signature Premier Properties Team to everyone I know. Stacy is a professional and genuine. I realize it won't always be this easy to sell your home, but I think you'd be hard pressed to find a better Realtor. Thanks again Stacy for this wonderful journey!

                        - Arun T. - West Babylon
                      • Stacy was a great realtor. She was pro active and aggressive. She would be in contact with us every single day and send us listings no matter what time or day it was. She knew exactly what we wanted. At the time, the market inventory and was very low. We were getting frustrated but she made it into a positive experience. Stacy fought hard for us and never gave up. She was always available via phone, email or text. I can't thank Stacy enough for her hard work and dedication. I would recommend Stacy to any friends or family members who is looking to sell or purchase a home.

                        - Steve & Alyssa M - Centereach
                      • We contacted Stacy on a recommendation from a friend, and got an immediate market assessment and proposal of a marketing plan to sell the house quickly.We had 3 offers in the first week and accepted a full price offer from a qualified buyer.Our experience with Stacy was excellent, would highly recommend her to others looking to sell their home.

                        - Scott S. - Babylon
                      • As a first time home buyer I didnt know anything about anything so I contacted a realtor off a real estate app and boy oh boy was that a bad idea. After about a week with this person I wont name I decided to ask around for recommendations for a realtor with actual knowledge and this is how I got Stacys contact info. Stacy was a breath of fresh air compared to what I was dealing with before her. Her knowledge about the market, the neighborhood I chose and everything in between was impeccable. In just under a month and countless days of searching with Stacy I had finally found the perfect home. She made searching fun, easy and painless and I will very much so recommend her to my friends and family. Ive been living in my new home for a week now and couldnt be happier so thank you Stacy!

                        - Michael S. - North Babylon
                      • Stacy was greatbt work with! She was very responsive and patient with any questions we had about the process. She was very helpful and I would recommend her services to anyone looking for a trustworthy and hardworking real estate agent!

                        - Jim & Rose W - Centerport
                      • Stacy was exactly what we were looking for in an agent to buy a home. She is knowledgeable about the process and about local areas. She is very professional and makes sure you find what you are looking for. She is always available, and if she isn't she sends her assistant Stevi in her place. Both Stacy and Stevi are down-to-earth and make the entire process as painless as possible. Within a month of meeting Stacy and Stevi, we were in our new home!

                        - Zach & Holly - Islip Terrace
                      • Stacy McFadden has been our realtor twice in the past 9 years. We initially met Stacy when we were looking to buy our first home. We were immediately impressed by how quickly she responded after we contacted her, as well as her keen knowledge of the homes for sale in the areas we were looking. Stacy is a hard-working, dedicated and reliable realtor who listens to her clients and finds the right home for them. Stacy found us a great starter home in a neighborhood she knew well, and we created many great memories there as a family. When we were ready to move on to something bigger, we knew there was no one else we would trust to help us navigate our way through the sale of our home. Stacy knew the comps in the area and what other houses recently sold for. Stacy accurately priced our home, and as a result of her marketing and expertise, we immediately had several offers on our home. As first-time home buyers, we had a ton of questions for Stacy. She was very patient with us and answered all of our questions and shared her knowledge with us. When it was time to sell our home, we had even more questions, and she educated us on the current real estate market. On both occasions, Stacy helped us through big life changes and made the purchase and sale of our home less stressful. I could not imagine working with any other realtor, and my husband and I highly recommend Stacy to all of our family and friends

                        - Ed & Erin S - North Babylon
                      • Stacy was great. She worked around our crazy schedule to show us houses and responded immediately any time we contacted her. She found us a great house in a nice neighborhood, which I didn't think would happen with our budget. Stacy had contacts for everything we needed, which was helpful because I'm new to the area. She was very accommodating with all of our needs. Stacy has continued to check in with us since closing. We found Stacy to be polite, professional, and sincere; therefore, we would highly recommend her

                        - Sierra & Will - West Babylon
                      • I worked with Stacy McFadden for my first home purchase and highly recommend her to anyone searching for a good, relatable, knowledable realtor. She used her experience and knowledge to guide me through the process and ensure that I fully understood what was happening by answering every question I had. Stacy showed me all different types of properties within my budget and explained to me how they could work for me, and, from there narrowed down our searches. Even upon entering homes, Stacy knew if a property WOULDNT work for me and would explain why certain properties might not be best for me. Stacy went above and beyond by taking the initiative to make sure I had taken advantage of all new-homeowner benefits. She really appreciates the fact that purchasing a home is a big deal for people and really delivers and proves her knowledge and reliability through the process. I will not be working with anyone else

                        - Jenn N. - West Islip
                      • I met Stacy a few years ago as the Sellers Broker on a house I purchased. Stacy's calm demeanor and get it done attitude won me over. She does a lot of work behind the scenes to make your transaction go smoothly. Unfortunately for her she is so good at her job Most of her clients don't ever see that. That is a tribute to her experience and professionalism. I was a little skeptical using Stacy as my buyers agent only because I know she didn't specialize in the neighborhoods I was looking to buy in. But, I gave her a shot bc I know how dedicated she is to her clients and am very glad that I did. She worked tirelessly to help me doing a ton of research answered all of my questions always in a timely manner. If I had to do it all over again, I would have used Stacy the only difference. I NEVER should have had any doubt. Thanks again for all your help on both my sale and purchase during a very rough time in my life

                        - Mike A. - North Babylon/Rockville Centre
                      • Stacy recently helped find my oldest son find and purchase his Condominium. I was very confident that she had his best interest on advising him along the way .She used her skills and experience to guide him through the process that can feel over whelming for a first time buyer . I trusted and appreciate the service she provided to him

                        - Gidget T - North Babylon
                      • When we decided to start looking for a house, I knew exactly who to call for advice. Stacy McFadden was very honest and helpful throughout this entire experience. She found us our dream home and sold ours quickly. Stacy was always available to answer our questions and guide us through the process. She not only took our feelings into consideration, she cared about our childrens needs as well. Stacy was more than a real estate agent. We now consider her a friend. We highly recommend Stacy to anybody in the buying/selling market

                        - Joe & Kristen R - East Islip
                      • If you need to buy or sell Stacy is the realtor you want. From day one she was extremely pleasant and helpful. Her knowledge of the process gave us piece of mind plus she was happy to answer any question we had with a great attitude. When it came to guide us she went above and beyond with every single need we had. Very professional, organized and thoughtful about our needs. Didn't waste time looking at properties that were not what we looked for. Always available and quick to respond. Would use her again without hesitation.

                        - Juan & Stephanie - North Babylon
                      • Stacy is the new agent I ever worked with , she had knowledge of the area we where looking in and she also has knowledge of houses and she taught us everything. Stacy found us our home and was with us the whole way through showing up for inspections and all the other proceedings leading up to closing. It didnt stop there Stacy still was very helpful any time I text her she answers in a second she told us about dinning and shopping and landscaping and even firewood. if you want to find your home without being rushed and not being taken then there is no other agent better than Stacy. I googled the best agent in the area and her picture pops up right away Im so glad we went with her I strongly suggest her to any couple looking for a house

                        - Chris & Tiersa - North Babylon
                      • We have used Stacy multiple times; she helped us buy our first home, sell my grandparents house, and most recently sell and buy at the same time. Every experience with her has been smooth and painless, when often times these processes can be messy and stressful. She knows so many helpful details about the neighborhoods and offers useful resources at every stage. I would recommend Stacy to anyone i know looking to purchase or sell a home

                        - Andew & Meghan - West Islip
                      • We have used Stacy multiple times; she helped us buy our first home, sell my grandparents house, and most recently sell and buy at the same time. Every experience with her has been smooth and painless, when often times these processes can be messy and stressful. She knows so many helpful details about the neighborhoods and offers useful resources at every stage. I would recommend Stacy to anyone i know looking to purchase or sell a home

                        - Andrew & Meghan - West Islip
                      • Stacy McFadden was our real estate agent that arranged the sale of our West Islip home in May of 2019. She was not the first realtor we interviewed, but it was clear she would be the last. From the initial interview onward, she was honest, forthright, and clear in her explanations, and reasoning behind her appraisal of our home. She displayed an air of confidence that was reassuring. During the entire process she was always reachable by phone, text or email, within minutes. When there were problems, and there will always be problems along the way, she always took a calm and level headed approach to solve the issue. Most importantly, she listened and was attentive to our needs and suggestions. Stacy is very personable and extremely easy to get along with. We wholeheartedly recommend her to all prospective buyers and sellers. She has a great deal of knowledge and expertise in properties of the South shore of Long Island. A final note, Stacy sold our home for our asking price, within one hour of signing our agreement with her. She led us through the entire process in a calm, professional, and relatively painless fashion

                        - Steve Klein & Nancy Bromberg - West Islip
                      • Stacy was very professional with the sale of my mother's house.The house was sold quickly and she always kept us informed about the progress of the sale.She was also available to discuss details of the sale.I would recommend to anyone trying to sell a house.

                        - Neil Twohill - Babylon
                      • If you want to assemble an "all star" team for your home buying or selling process, start with Stacy. She is truly 5 stars across the board. We chose Stacy after reading her Zillow reviews and meeting with her in person. It was the best decision we could have made. From start to finish she was there every step of the way. She is quickly responsive seemingly 24/7. During the process you spend plenty of time with your agent. So you want someone who is down to earth, professional, understands your wants and needs and easy to get along with. Stacy is all of those things. I am confident we got top dollar for the house we sold specifically because Stacy's efforts. We landed our "forever home" thanks to Stacy. I strongly recommend you choose her to buy or sell your home. She's awesome!

                        - Michael Rutcofsky - North Babylon/Dix Hills
                      • Stacy is an amazing realtor! She is so great to work with and has so much knowledge in real estate. She helped us find our first house 4 years ago and we did not hesitate to contact her to sell our house and find something a bit larger for our growing family. She listed our house, it sold in like 11 days and then she found us our dream house to purchase within the next week! It all went so fast, she knew exactly what we were looking for. She is always available for any questions throughout the entire process, which made it less stressful with the sale and purchase all at once. Not only does she help you buy or sell a house, she also keeps in touch after the fact, just to see how everything is going. I would recommend Stacy to anyone who wants a realtor they can trust to sell their house or find their dream home -

                        - Deana Ward - Deer Park/West Islip