Find the perfect Buffalo real estate agent

We analyze millions of home sales to find the best performing real estate agents.

Please enter a valid city and state.
Ex: San Francisco, CA
Find an agent

Top Buffalo real estate agents

There are 44 real estate agents in Buffalo, WY but we use data to find the best ones. HomeLight compares the agent performance data in your area to find real estate agents who get the job done 1.7x days faster than the average Buffalo, WY real estate agent.

"I was thrilled with the service Homelight provided. Within 10 minutes of logging into the site, I had 3 real estate agents calling me about listing my home. I was very happy and would use them again."

Kurt H.

See how 20 of the top real estate agents in Buffalo, WY stack up

April Poley
The Property Shop, LLC
About April

I help buyers and sellers throughout Northeastern Wyoming. I've lived in Sheridan, Buffalo, and Gillette, so I have a lot of knowledge of the entire region and what the lifestyle is like in each of these communities. I am a full-time agent and the broker and owner of The Property Shop.

April's reviews

"I work with April frequently as I also work in the industry.... When it came time to buy a home, I h..."

See more reviews
Townhome Transactions
8
Single Family Home Transactions
76
Condo Transactions
2
Achievements
  • Top Negotiator 2020
  • Top Producer 2020
  • Move Safe Certified 2020
Ask a question
View profile
Judi M Holmes
Century 21 BHJ Realty, Inc.
About Judi M

I am a FULL TIME agent in the Johnson County area that specializes in Residential Real Estate. As a result of being actively involved in the day-to-day Real Estate business, I am on top of this continually changing industry. My passion for people and love helping them achieve their goals and dreams is what keeps me motivated! I have been in Buffalo for over 7 years and have been an active and connected member of the community and our church. We came from Billings, Montana, where I practiced Real Estate prior to moving to Buffalo. I was always plugged in there, as well as with the community and our church. My husband, Lonnie, was given the opportunity to transfer with his company here to Buffalo. Our family has made this community our home - we have three children - Michael, Matthew and Ryleigh. I hope you love this community as well. I would love to help you with your Real Estate needs here whether you are a Seller or Buyer.

Single Family Home Transactions
130
Condo Transactions
2
TIC Transactions
0
Achievements
  • Top Negotiator 2020
Ask a question
View profile
Mandy Koltiska, Associate Broker
Koltiska Real Estate Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
About Mandy

Mandy is a top producing REALTOR in Sheridan County and will work hard for you; whether a first time home buyer, selling your long time family home or building your dream home! Read what others have said about Mandy, search for property, then contact Mandy to get started in a smooth real estate transaction!

Single Family Home Transactions
180
Townhome Transactions
2
TIC Transactions
0
Ask a question
View profile
Kitty Merrill
Buffalo Realty LLC
About Kitty

Kitty Merrill can help you with residential, business, commercial or farm and ranch property needs. She has over 40 years of experience and has received many prestigious awards such as: Coldwell Banker President's Elite Award, Coldwell Banker International President's Circle, and consistently placed among the top 5% for Coldwell Banker USA. Here in Johnson County Kitty has been recognized as the Top Listing Agent, and Top Sales Agent. We are extremely privileged to have Kitty, as a part of our team!

Townhome Transactions
1
Condo Transactions
5
Single Family Home Transactions
51
Ask a question
View profile
Tami Hinson
1st Class Realty
About Tami

Hometown broker & Gillette's #1 Agent! 15 years experience in handling everything from foreclosures to the fabulously expensive. I enjoy working hard assisting both buyers and sellers in having the smoothest transaction possible. It is my pleasure to help you find that perfect home and to assist you through the steps necessary for a successful transaction. 2016, 2017, 2018 #1 Agent in Gillette & Northeast Wyoming Named to RE/MAX National Hall of Fame in only 4 years 2013 #1 IN HOMES SOLD for RE/MAX Mountain States Region - HELPING 60 FAMILIES 2012 #1 IN HOMES SOLD for RE/MAX Mountain States Region - HELPING 54 FAMILIES REALTOR® certification Ranked in the Top 10% of Realtors in the District for 9 Consecutive Years Platinum ClubTop Agent Award

Tami's reviews

"Very knowledgeable on home sales and what's going on, Very Impressive, Was taken care of very well a..."

See more reviews
Townhome Transactions
9
Single Family Home Transactions
28
TIC Transactions
0
Ask a question
View profile
Cristy J Kinghorn
Buffalo Realty LLC
About Cristy J

Cristy J is a real estate agent with Buffalo Realty LLC. We have data on 0 of Cristy J’s transactions. This real estate agent most often represents the seller (80% of the time), but they also have experience representing the buyer side of transactions, with 89 deals recorded. Here’s what we know about Cristy J’s work: - Cristy J has sold homes for as much as $875,000. - this real estate agent is skilled in fast home sales: they have listings that have sold in as little as 13 days. - Cristy J is an agent who sells homes for top dollar.

Condo Transactions
8
Single Family Home Transactions
230
TIC Transactions
0
Achievements
  • Top Producer 2020
Ask a question
View profile
Laurel Lunstrum
Brokerage House Realty, Inc
About Laurel

Laurel works under Brokerage House Realty, Inc. Laurel has sold 1.37x the number of single family homes as the average agent in the area. We’ve recorded data for 97 of Laurel’s transactions. Laurel has worked with sellers 86% of the time, and has represented the buyer in 39 recorded transactions. Here’s a little about Laurel’s real estate experience: - Laurel has sold homes for as much as $2,075,000. - this real estate agent is skilled in fast home sales: they have listings that have sold in as little as 17 days. HomeLight has data on 4 transactions Laurel has done in Casper. Laurel has closed 1 more home sales than the average agent in the area.

Single Family Home Transactions
89
TIC Transactions
0
Townhome Transactions
0
Ask a question
View profile
Marisa Stott
Coldwell Banker The Legacy Group
About Marisa

Marisa is a real estate agent with Coldwell Banker The Legacy Group. Here’s what we know about Marisa’s work: - Marisa recently sold one home for $290,000. - this real estate agent is skilled in fast home sales: they have listings that have sold in as little as 18 days. - Marisa is a top dollar real estate agent. - this real estate agent is on a home selling roll: their transaction history shows that they have sold 250% more homes this year than last.

Condo Transactions
1
Single Family Home Transactions
24
TIC Transactions
0
Ask a question
View profile
Carl Wuestehube
Tri-Star Realty
About Carl

Carl is a real estate agent with Tri-Star Realty. Carl has sold 0.59x the number of single family homes as the average agent in the area. We’ve recorded data for 10 of Carl’s transactions. Carl has worked with sellers 100% of the time, and has represented the buyer in 1 recorded transactions. Here’s what we know about Carl’s work: - Carl recently sold one home for $350,000. - Carl has sold homes in as little as 39 days. - Carl is a top dollar real estate agent.

Condo Transactions
1
Single Family Home Transactions
23
TIC Transactions
0
Ask a question
View profile
Shelbie Wolski
Coldwell Banker The Legacy Group
About Shelbie

Shelbie works under Coldwell Banker The Legacy Group.

TIC Transactions
0
Townhome Transactions
0
Short Sales
0
Ask a question
View profile

Find your perfect real estate agent in Buffalo

Please enter a valid city and state.
Ex: San Francisco, CA
Get Started

Why you need a top real estate agent in Buffalo, WY

The 44 active real estate agents in Buffalo move 48 off the market in 109 days on average. Top Buffalo real estate agents move properties off the housing market 45.21 days faster than average agents.

Top Seller's Agents

A top seller’s agent in Buffalo makes 8.1% more dollars for sellers, wraps up the selling process 45.21 days faster, and sells 1.7x more homes than the average agent.

Sale Price / List Price (%)

Days on Market
Lower is better

Homes Sold / Yr


Top Buyer's Agents

Top buyer’s agents in Buffalo help home buyers purchase 1.6x more homes when they're measured against the average real estate agent in Buffalo. Top buyer’s agents also save clients $58,906 on transactions.

Condos Sold / Yr

Homes Purchased / Yr

Sale Price / List Price (%)
Lower is better

"Our realtor recommendation was perfect! She helped explain everything and the whole process went very smoothly. We would definitely recommend HomeLight to anyone selling a house."

Kelly P.

"HomeLight was very prompt and helpful when I began my Realtor search. They were able to connect me with numerous local Realtors in my area which in turn got my house sold quickly... I would in fact enjoy using the HomeLight service again."

Osmil C.

"I would like to thank you for finding my local real estate agent. Within a week, we had multiple offers at a substantially higher price. We ended up selling the home to a buyer with an all cash offer and we were able to close very quickly."

Roger P..

Check out some of our other resources for Buffalo homeowners

When's the best time to sell my home?
Use housing market data in your city to learn the best and worst months to sell your home.
How much commission do real estate agents make?
Use this calculator and real estate agent commissions data to find out.
Sell your house in Buffalo fast
Find out what cash buyers are willing to pay for your home right now.
Advice from America’s Top Agents
Get the latest real estate tips and learn how to sell your home faster and for more money.
Simple real estate calculators
Use our free calculators to help you make informed financial decisions when buying or selling a home.
Find out what your home is worth
Get a free estimated value of your home in less than 2 minutes.

Find your perfect real estate agent in Buffalo, WY

Please enter a valid city and state.
Ex: San Francisco, CA
Get Started