Top Real Estate Agents in Setauket, NY

We analyze millions of home sales to find the best performing real estate agents & REALTORS® for your personalized needs.

100% free
Less than 2 minutes
Only top agents

Find a Setauket, NY Real Estate Agent Today.

HomeLight compares historical data on all of Setauket, NY’s 39 real estate agents to find you the best of the best. The city’s top 3% agents do 1.7x more deals a year than the average agent, and move homes off the market 25.0% quicker.

"When I decided to sell my house I was at a loss as to where to start. I came across HomeLight. What blessing that was. My Realtor was great. I would recommend HomeLight to anyone selling a house. It is a great place to start."

Ed SSold with a HomeLight Agent

Top Setauket REALTOR® Rankings

Top Agents List updated on April 16th, 2024
Gail Carillo snapshot

Coldwell Banker American Homes

Ranked #1 Team Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage for number of transactions, Long Island & Queens in 2016 & 2017 Ranked #1 Team Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage for Mortgage, Title & Relocation in 2016 Business Philosophy Gail Carillo and The "Carillo Team" are dedicated to Premium Customer Servic...

Gail Carillo's reviews

"Gail Carillo was the consummate professional to work with. I had interviewed several agents when the time came to sell my house and Gail easily surpassed everyone and my wife and I immediately felt comfortable with her approach, knowledge and affability. Gail delivered on all our expectations and was truly someone ..." see more reviews

Home Transactions

261

Average Price Point

$520K

Years of Experience

25

Michael Carroll snapshot

RE/MAX Best

Professional Real Estate Broker Michael Carroll of RE/MAX Best, with offices in West Babylon, Port Washington, Ronkonkoma ranked No. 9 overall in the United States among RE/MAX agents for Total Individual Commissions in 2019. Number 1 in Transactions in New York State in 2019. This is the fourth straight year that M...

Home Transactions

227

Average Price Point

$430K

Years of Experience

40

Amanda Eckart snapshot

Celebrate Your Home Team with Real Broker NY, LLC

Proud to be among the top 1% of Long Island Real Estate Brokers. Nationally ranked Real Trends America's Best Real Estate Professionals 2020, 2019, 2018. Our team helped over 109 clients buy or sell a home in 2020 and we'd love to assist you! CELEBRATE YOUR HOME TEAM VS SINGLE AGENT >>Over 38 years of combined rea...

Amanda Eckart's reviews

"Amanda, Anthony, and Beth have all been so wonderful to work with. CYH helped us buy a home and sell a home and both times it was a great experience through it all. Very highly recommend!..." see more reviews

Home Transactions

224

Average Price Point

$600K

Years of Experience

20

Find your personalized Top Agent

Only the top agents, free and unbiased, save time and hassle

Zachary Scher snapshot

Signature Premier Properties

Lead of Team Scher at Signature Premier Properties in East Setauket, New York – the #1 Overall Team at Signature Premier Properties, possesses a dynamic combination of industry knowledge, enthusiasm and a true desire to provide his clients with conscientious, dedicated service. Rapidly ascending to the top of the Lo...

Home Transactions

171

Average Price Point

$560K

Years of Experience

8

Nicole Schwartz snapshot

RE/MAX Integrity Leaders

Nicole Schwartz is a Long Island native with a vast knowledge of the island and an intense love for the real estate industry. She provides unending dedication to helping each family and individual get to their next place in life. Nicole understands that purchasing and/or selling a home is one of the biggest decision...

Nicole Schwartz's reviews

"Nicole was like a breath of fresh air! A very knowledgeable, skillful, personable professional, who is certainly at the top of her game; able to moved with lightening speed in accomplishing all the desired goals within a very short time, stress-free!! It was a real delight to know Nicole; our family is very thankf..." see more reviews

Home Transactions

157

Average Price Point

$600K

Years of Experience

9

Lina Lopes snapshot

Douglas Elliman Real Estate

WHAT SETS US APART FROM THE REST? ...

Home Transactions

125

Average Price Point

$510K

Years of Experience

34

Find your personalized Top Agent

Only the top agents, free and unbiased, save time and hassle

Annette Mina snapshot

Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Sales specialist Annette Mina gives her undivided attention and utmost hands-on guidance to every buyer and seller she represents. "I want people to feel that I've gone above and beyond, and that I've done a thorough job in advising them so they can count on me anytime for future advice should the need arise." Annet...

Home Transactions

107

Average Price Point

$570K

Years of Experience

12

Lisa Jaeger snapshot

Douglas Elliman Real Estate

The Jaeger Team is a full service Team of 10 licensed agents serving all of Long Island from Montauk to Manhattan. We are the Unions #1 Referred Real Estate Team! Our company, Douglas Elliman is #1 on Long Island for 43 CONSECUTIVE years! We have been one of the Top 5 Teams on the Island from 2005 to 2021. You won't...

Home Transactions

94

Average Price Point

$590K

Years of Experience

22

Sharon Satkowski snapshot

Re/max Benchmark Realty Group

Sharon is a real estate agent with Re/max Benchmark Realty Group. Here’s what we know about Sharon’s work: - Sharon recently sold one home for $422,500. - Sharon has sold homes in as little as 57 days. - Sharon is a top dollar real estate agent. Sharon has completed 2 transactions in Walden....

Home Transactions

48

Average Price Point

$510K

Years of Experience

11

Benjamin Dunevitz snapshot

Silversons Realty, Llc

Benjamin is a real estate agent with Silversons Realty, Llc....

Home Transactions

45

Average Price Point

$600K

Years of Experience

12

HomeLightNew York
Setauket Top Real Estate Agents

How we select the best Setauket agents

At HomeLight, our vision is a world where every real estate transaction is simple, certain, and satisfying.
We've analyzed transaction data of local real estate agents and REALTORS® across 6 distinct metrics to recommend a few of Setauket's top Real Estate Agents.
Reviewed
39
Vetted
20
Top Picks
19

Top real estate agents stats at a glance

HomeLight can match you with real estate agents in the top 3% of performers who, on average, sell 1.2x faster and for 93.8% more money.

Sale Price / List Price (%)

Days on Market

Lower is better

Homes Sold / Year

Find your perfect real estate agent in Setauket, NY

Tools for sellers & buyers

Check out some of our other resources for Setauket homeowners

Client FAQs

What does a top real estate agent do?

Top real estate agents have more local expertise, prepare in-depth market analyses, and have industry connections that you can’t find by yourself. They know your neighborhood like the back of their hand and use their market knowledge to sell your home faster than the average agent and for money.

What should you look for when interviewing a real estate agent in Setauket?

When you sell a house, your real estate agent becomes your business partner, financial advisor, and emotional support system. It’s crucial to partner with someone you trust, so make sure you’re looking for an agent who can answer all of your questions with confidence during the interview. During this process, you want to get to know the agent’s business and find out how well they know the area. You’re listening for things that signal experience, expertise in your community, and workload. Selling a home takes an enormous amount of work, so you need an agent who’s got a plan for prep, pricing, and marketing and who is ready to roll up their sleeves to get the job done.

How important is it to hire a top real estate agent in Setauket?

Our data shows that the top 5% of listing agents sell homes for as much as (+9%) more than the average real estate agent. A great agent makes a difference when you buy a house, too: We’ve found that the top 5% of buyer's agents on average save their clients 2.5% more on their home purchase. So, whether you’re in the market to find your dream home or sell your house at a great price, the right agent matters. We encourage you to connect with a top real estate agent if you’re buying or selling a home in Setauket, NY.

When is the right time to hire a real estate agent in Setauket?

The best window to contact an agent to sell your home is anywhere from three to six months in advance of your list date. When you start the search for an agent several months before hitting the market, there’s plenty of time to find the best agent, make key renovations, and market your home effectively, all of which are essential steps in selling your home for a great price. You can also hire an agent based on the best time to sell to take advantage of seasonal and cyclical trends in the market.

The right time to hire a real estate agent depends on the temperature of the housing market. For example, the best time to sell is in May. And since it takes around 3 months to close on a home, you should list in February. We recommend that you hire a real estate agent as soon as you're thinking of selling your home. Generally speaking, that's anywhere from 3 to 6 months prior to your desired move date.

What is the average real estate agent commission for agents in Setauket?

While individual real estate agent commissions do vary, most real estate agents in Setauket work for 6% of the home price.

Why should I use HomeLight to find a Setauket real estate agent?

HomeLight analyzes all real estate agent in Setauket to bring you custom, unbiased, data-driven recommendations. We use actual home sales transaction data to compare Setauket real estate agent and will only introduce you to the top performing agents. They do not pay to advertise on our site and we do not pay to list them. To give you the best object recommendations, we consider things like: how fast a real estate agent sells, how many properties they work on, how much money they save or earn their clients, and what cities and neighborhoods they specialize in. You can trust that we’ll match you with the right agents for your needs.