Justin Steill Real Estate Agent at Berkshire Hathaway Home services Indiana ~ Homes With Steill

Justin Steill

Real Estate Agent at
Berkshire Hathaway Home services Indiana ~ Homes With Steill

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins

Browse homes for sale in markets that Justin serves

Find top agents in markets that Justin serves

Specialties

  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Farm Property
  • Vacation Home
  • Probate
  • New Construction
  • Luxury Specialist
  • Retirement Specialist
  • Land Specialist
  • Relocations
  • Waterfront Specialist

Agent Highlights

Justin gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Carmel agent.
Justin is a SFH expert - working with over 66% more single family homes than the average Carmel agent.
Justin has great Condo experience - having sold more condos than the average agent.
I recently sold my home and bought a new one with the assistance of Justin and his team. To say that I’m happy and satisfied would be an absolute understatement. Stunned and overjoyed at the speed w...

Justin's Transactions

More about Justin Steill

As the owner of a top-performing real estate team in Westfield and Carmel, I am passionate about building relationships, fostering connections, and serving as a trusted resource for all your real estate needs. Whether buying, selling, or investing, our proven process ensures exceptional results. We are committed to delivering the best possible outcomes for our clients. Our Expertise: • New Construction | Downsizing | First-Time Homebuyers | Senior Moves • Luxury Homes | Relocation | Custom Builds Highlights: • Top 1% Team in the Indy Metro market out of 10,000 agents, with over $500M sold (2017–2024) • 20+ years of experience in the real estate industry • Lifestyle Manager: We believe you’re not just buying a home—you’re buying a lifestyle. • Innovative marketing strategies and professional staging to sell your home efficiently and at the best price. Client Success ...
Show More
Education

BS, Purdue University

Other Certifications

National Association of Realtors® , MIBOR

License Number

RB14042626

Justin Steill's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Justin Steill

  • Justin listed and sold my home

      I recently sold my home and bought a new one with the assistance of Justin and his team. To say that I’m happy and satisfied would be an absolute understatement. Stunned and overjoyed at the speed with which he sold my existing house and found my dream house would be much more accurate. I had put off buying a new house because of the anxiety it always causes; the moving, the packing, the uncertainty of a quick sale at a fair price and what if I’m between homes? For those reasons I put it off and looked on my own for over a year and then one day I just felt it was time to move on so I contacted Justin’s office and he called me back within an hour. I told him my very exacting criteria and the hardest was being within a half mile of the Monon Trail or Nickle Plate trail, at my price range and in Hamilton County. Go. Clearly that was an acceptable challenge because after setting up 4 different searches and emailing them to me every day I was able to find my dream house almost immediately. Meanwhile Justin’s team came out and measured my house, interviewed me about upgrades I had done and then scheduled the professional photography. The entire process was so much more high-end than I had experienced in the past (and I have sold and bought a few houses in my time). We listed my house at noon on Wednesday and I think we had 3 offers that evening. By Friday noon which was only 2 days later we had 6 or 7, I was just stunned! Only having my house on the market 2 days was a dream and one I hadn’t even considered, it was just incredible! And a large majority was at asking price or above, which again, I was stunned. Once all the offers were compiled and vetted, Justin and I talked through them and went with the one that best fit my situation and comfort level. Justin had also recommended a fantastic mortgage broker that I would gladly use again and a title company that I was very happy with. All in all, there is very little I would change and what I would change had nothing to do with Justin or his team. So if you’re looking for a team with incredible experience, in-depth market knowledge and a realtor with fantastic negotiating skills, Homes with Steill is the company you’re looking for. Sincerely, Amy Powers

      Show More
    • Justin listed and sold my home

        We would have Justin as our agent again without hesitation. He has represented us as both buyer and seller. Very knowledgable. Takes time to listen and responds to request. Takes care of details to make selling house less stressful

      • Justin listed and sold my home

          Justin Steill and his team were immediately recommended to us from several of his past clients. When we met with Justin for the first time, we knew right away we really liked this guy! He’s professional, friendly, and an all around good person. You know that in the first five minutes of meeting him. We had a flawless transaction withJustin. His team is exactly that….a team! If there is anything you need, there is always someone there to help. What a great experience…I can’t say enough good things.

        • Justin helped me buy a home

            Excellent. He and his team did a great job with all around service and communication. They were very professional and friendly. I will highly recommend him to others.

          • Justin helped me buy a home

              Justin did an excellent job of finding us a home that suited our family; he was incredibly responsive and great at communication. We owe him a lot!

            • Justin listed and sold my home

                He is the best!!!!

              • Justin Steill and his team are licensed and local Realtors serving the Indianapolis metro area. They have a powerful network and knowledge. I was very impressed with the performance and enthusiasm. I would definitely recommend them.

                - Rich Ryu
              • Justin Steill exemplifies what a great Realtor is about; caring, knowledgeable, persistent & hard working to name a few attributes. Having been involved in several transactions with him, it's easy to recognize that he is a level above.

                - Jeffrey Dettelbach
              • Justin Steill and his team are an excellent group of real estate agents. We would definitely recom- mend them and work with them again. Besides being great agents, they also provide a great online tool to help guide you to the right property/home.

                - Blaine Cooper
              • The Homes With Steill group are an example of what realtors should aspire to be. They keep you informed and up to date during the buying and selling process. Not only does Justin have the best socks in the business, he also has the best attitude and knowledge. You will find working with this group a pleasure. Our family is a fan.

                - Shepherd Family
              • Extremely professional. Great attention to detail. Got two offers on our very first day the house was listed, one of which was for our full asking price!! It doesn't get much better than that.

                - SKW
              • Justin listed a home for us in the Brookside neighborhood and it sold very quickly. He knows the West- field/Carmel area very well and had a very solid marketing plan to drive showings of the house. He works at a high level of detail from listing to close. Thanks to Justin, we received a full price offer on our home!

                - Tim Siefker
              • Justin Steill helped me sell a rental property in Westfield, IN. I initially hired a different realtor, but after 6 months the property had received virtually no activity. I was referred to Justin by someone who had worked with him before. I hired Justin soon after our initial meeting, and he immediately started driving interest in the property. Justin gave me great advice on ways to improve my rental property, which increased its value and market appeal. Once I began making Justins recommended changes we were able to convert the interest he was generating into offers, which led to a quick and lucrative sale!Justin took great care in walking us through the home marketing process. He was open to our ideas on what we needed and wanted to see happen, and he worked with us to balance that against market data to come to agree- ment on price and process for the selling of our home. The hard part seemed to come after we had a buyer on our home. He helped us negotiate terms, inspection items and navigate the mortgage process to keep our stress levels even. He was accessible and responsive, and generally had an answer that moved us toward the goal to get out of our previous home and into our new home. He was always very professional, prompt and followed up.

                - Amy Slane
              • Justin Steill and his team were immediately recommended to us from several of his past clients. When we met with Justin for the first time, we knew right away we really liked this guy! Hes professional, friendly, and an all around good person. You know that in the first five minutes of meeting him. We had a flawless transaction with Justin. His team is exactly that....a team! If there is anything you need, there is always someone there to help. What a great experience...I cant say enough good things.

                - Erica Myers
              • Justin has served as my agent in a real estate transaction and I felt he did a great job of keeping me informed on the details and negotiating with the other party we were working with. He and his team made sure to drive a win-win end result keeping both sides satisfied. I would recommend Homes With Steill as an excellent realty group.

                - Sargent