Katie Malott Real Estate Agent at Compass Indiana

Katie Malott

Real Estate Agent at
Compass Indiana

Get introduced
Usually responds in 30 mins
  • First Time Home Buyers
  • Luxury Specialist
  • New Construction
  • Relocations
  • Investment Properties
  • Waterfront Specialist

Is Katie the right agent for you?

Answer a few questions to see how well Katie's strengths match your needs

Are you looking to Buy or Sell?

Agent Highlights

Katie gets the job done - completing more sales than the average Indianapolis agent by 3%.
Katie is a SFH expert - working with over 68% more single family homes than the average Indianapolis agent.
Katie has great Condo experience - having sold 11 more condos than the average agent.

Katie's Transactions

More about Katie Malott

Katie Malott has been serving the Indianapolis area as a Realtor for 11 years and has been full steam ahead with her business, leadership, & involvement in the Real Estate Community. As Katie’s business continued to grow, Katie established Malott Realty Group in 2017. Keeping her client’s best interest, a top priority, she prides herself in communications, professionalism, and determination that she provides to her clients and peers throughout the transaction process. Her love for Real Estate does not stop with her production of transactions, Katie graduated from MIBOR Real Academy of Leadership and is highly involved in many MIBOR organizations & committees. She was honored as MIBOR’s Realtor of the Year for 2021. Katie has a passion for giving back to the community through volunteering in the community with such as Gleaners Food Pantry and Habitat for Humanity. HomeLight ranks Katie as one of the top 18% of agents for single family homes.

University of Denver

Other Certifications

NAR Licensed


100% Club 2017, 100% Club 2016, Executive Club 2015, Executive Club 2014, RE/MAX Legends 2017 Legend of the Year

License Number


Katie Malott's Reviews & Ratings

Tell us about your experience with
Katie Malott

  • Katie helped me buy a home

      Katie was an excellent realtor! She was able to answer all of our questions and she did a great job negotiating on our home. Katie was very attentive and always responded in a timely manner. We would definitely recommend her to our friends and family!

    • Katie helped me buy a home

        Katie was wonderful to work with. She sought to understand our needs. Kept us well-informed during the entire process. We have recommended her to several other people who have all been pleased with her services. We would definitely use her again as our agent

      • Katie listed and sold my home

          Katie went out her way to help me sell my home.. I would highly recommend

        • Katie listed and sold my home

            Katie did a great job! We used her to sell a house and purchase a new house. She found answers to our questions, guided us through the closing process, and was very professional. We would definitely use her again.

          • Katie never responded to my request


            • "We very much appreciated Katie's knowledge and patience with the home search and buying. She was wonderful to work with!"

              - Greg A
            • "Katie listened to us - shared with us what matters in this area/ community for home buying now and resale value down the road. Simply incredible -"

              - Tyler & Maggie S
            • "Katie could not have been more amazing throughout our entire buying and selling process. She was ALWAYS available to patiently answer our many questions, provided great input and feedback and tirelessly advocated on our behalf. She did an incredible job for us and we would recommend her to anyone!"

              - David & Gabi Y
            • "Katie did a great job with helping us purchase our first home. She communicated well with our seller as well as our broker. Thank you for everything!"

              - Madalyn K
            • "She is A-MAZING! Best Realtor EVER!"

              - Brittany M
            • "Katie Malott was so great to work with. I would recommend her to anyone and everyone that is ready to purchase a home. She made sure my needs were met, and even if we passed on a house she kept looking until we found the right one. That's what made it great was her initiative to make us happy. I would recommend Katie, because not only is she a professional at her job, but she works hard at making the buyers happy. Katie doesn't stop until things are right, and we the buyers are happy. I really enjoyed working with Katie. She is awesome."

              - Heather G
            • "Katie was wonderful. She is very knowledgeable and eager to please her clients. Katie has gone above and beyond expectations. She is so patient. We looked everywhere and it took us months and months of going back and forth on what we wanted and needed. I would highly recommend Katie. She is a people pleaser and above all wants her clients to be happy. Thanks To Katie our family of 5 is happy with our first Home purchase!"

              - Angela A
            • "Katie works on a 24/7 schedule. I love knowing I can text or call her at any given moment and she's so quick to respond. It's nice to know you have a close friend through the process. She's still answering my questions even after I've closed and moved in.Katie was also very patient with me as I only wanted to live in a certain neighborhood and am quite picky. I looked there for over a year before finding the one. She respected that and sent notifications as soon as anything came up in the complex. We were the first to see the place I bought the day it went on the market. She knew exactly what to write up and how to write it as the seller only showed the house a few more times the next morning and cancelled the rest of the showings they had lined up by accepting my offer. I'm happy she was there to guide me the way as I would have been lost without her."

              - Jessica M
            • "We were completely satisfied"

              - Dena F
            • "Katie is a go-getter! She has a plan from the start and takes action immediately. She is quick to obtain information, communicate, and follow through. We loved working with her, she listed to us and took our thoughts into consideration. She was wonderful to work with and made the entire process simple, smooth, and easy!"

              - Lisa P
            • "We loved working with Katie. It wasn't easy to find our specific needs for our paralyzed son....she just worked so diligently to help in any way she could. The realities we have worked with in the past was more like a used car salesman: just out to make a buck. Katie would answer any questions we ask or find out the answer if she didn't know promptly. She is a great gal to work with and we appreciate her so much! When I see Katie, I give her a hug. She is very personable!"

              - Steve & Sherry K
            • "Katie Malott was great. She always got back to me in a timely manner and helped us every step of the way. She was creative on solving problems that arose and worked very hard for us."

              - Elizabeth S
            • "Katie Malott did a great job as our realtor. She was able to interpret what we were looking for in a property and found the perfect house. We would strongly recommend Katie to anyone looking to buy a house in the Zionsville area!"

              - Nick S
            • "Katie Malott did a tremendous job as our realtor. The process was extremely easy and our house sold very quickly thanks to her expertise. We would strongly recommend her to anyone looking to buy/sell a house!"

              - Lauren S
            • "Katie Malott made what was an emotionally difficult process easy and stress free. She handled the nitty gritty details that I didn't want to think about and went above and beyond in communicating with me and with contractors coming in and out. She was always available for questions and Very relaxed and comfortable in all communications. She made selling and buying a house feel much simpler than I ever imagined. I'm so happy I chose Katie to help me sell and move on to the next phase."

              - Laura J
            • "Katie went above and beyond to make the selling experience easy and smooth. She was responsive whenever I had a need and she did everything with the upmost positivity and professionalism. I had already relocated to a new city when during the selling process, and Katie did whatever it took to make things easy on me being 4 hours away.I can't say enough good things about her and I would highly recommend her to anyone.Thanks Katie!!"

              - Scott H
            • "Katie was absolutely perfect. Her expert knowledge made everything very easy. She was always available when we had questions, and made us feel like a priority even though she had other clients. If we ever buy/sell another home, I'm definitely using Katie Malott."

              - Brian H
            • "My husband and I were very picky when looking for homes. We looked everywhere from Clermont to Fishers. Katie was willing to take us any and everywhere we wanted to go. I never felt like we were putting her out. I genuinely felt like she would keep looking with us for as long as it took to find exactly what we wanted. She had to have emergency surgery but didn't let that stop her! We were supposed to go see a house and she had another agent go in her place. She was even sending follow up emails from her hospital room to hear our feedback about the house! Once we chose the house we wanted, there were a lot of things that needed to be fixed first and Katie was so patient with my to do list and communicating with the other realtor/sellers to get things accomplished!"

              - Christina B
            • "My husband and I worked with Katie to sell our home and purchase a new one. She was extremely professional, very attentive, always accessible and a pleasure to work with at all times. She followed up with us after every showing and gave us detailed feedback on the comments. She followed up diligently on any and all leads to sell our home.While purchasing a home we were unsure of the exact styles we wanted but knew the areas we liked. Katie put together a list of homes to visit so we could narrow down our likes and dislikes. What we really appreciated is that she knew a lot about the homes we were visiting but didn't pressure or push us on any of them. I have recommended my family and friends to her and would love to work with her again in the future."

              - Jason & Jessie S
            • "Katie was always available for a phone call, always open to viewing a house on our schedule, and always had answers for our questions. Once, she even braved a blizzard and climbed through a foot of snow to help us get to a house to view."

              - Daniel P
            • "Katie Malott worked hard to find us a home that we absolutely love. When it was time to close she drove communication and put us in an excellent position to negotiate a great price. If you are looking for a realtor that makes the buying process fun and rewarding, go with Katie."

              - Joey M