SendCancel
By clicking "Send", I consent to HomeLight’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and I consent to have HomeLight or one of its partners to contact me via autodialed phone calls and text messages, and prerecorded messages, on the landline or cell number I provided even if I'm on any Do-Not-Call list and even if I am charged for the call or text. I understand that my consenting is not a condition of my receiving HomeLight’s services, and that I can call 866-627-3398 for services if I do not consent.

Message Sent!

A HomeLight concierge will reach out to confirm your details and connect you with this Agent.  Upon your request, we will also connect you with up to 2 additional top agents that meet your criteria.
We use historical and public real estate transaction data to identify the top performing real estate agents in your area. Learn more


Close

Find the perfect Fishers Island real estate agent

We analyze millions of home sales to find the best performing real estate agents.

Top Fishers Island real estate agents

HomeLight looks at every one of the 112 active Fishers Island, NY real estate agents and measures how they stack up against the average agent. In Fishers Island, the top 3% of agents buy and sell in 133 days and work on 511 homes.


HomeLight found me the perfect Realtor. He did a great job of staging my home and took terrific pictures while respecting my wishes. The home sold in one day. I couldn't have had a better experience.

Sharon K
New York

Why you need a top real estate agent in Fishers Island, NY

Average real estate agents in Fishers Island, NY leave homes on the market for 133 days, while top real estate agents sell in 87 days. Fishers Island’s 112 real estate agents with active listings sell 89 homes on average.

Top Seller's Agents

Top seller’s agents in Fishers Island make clients 4.9% more dollars, sell homes in 46.22 days more efficiently, and work with 1.8x as many homes as the average real estate agent in the same city.

Sale price / List price (%)

Days on market
Lower is better

Homes sold / yr


Top Buyer's Agents

Top buyer’s agents in Fishers Island save their clients $168,882 on their new home. Buyer’s agents in Fishers Island buy 1.7x more houses than the average agent.

Condos sold / yr

Homes purchased / yr

Sale price / list price (%)
Lower is better

See how some of the real estate agents in Fishers Island, NY stack up

Tim Bray

William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

Fishers Island Listings Sold

4

Average Days on Market

140

Average Over Asking

$50k

Michele Peters

Randall, Realtors Real L iving

Fishers Island Listings Sold

4

Average Over Asking

$21k

Condo Transactions

16

Katy Fetherston

Randall Realtors, Real Living

Fishers Island Listings Sold

4

Average Over Asking

$43k

Average Days on Market

160

Bonnie Call

Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage

Average Days on Market

120

Average Over Asking

$65k

Condo Transactions

33

Gregory Hanner

Garden Realty

Average Over Asking

$65k

Average Days on Market

160

Fishers Island Listings Sold

1

Gina Morin

Executive Real Estate

Average Over Asking

$65k

Average Days on Market

130

Fishers Island Listings Sold

1

Ann Burgess

Prudential Connecticut Realty

Fishers Island Listings Sold

4

Average Days on Market

140

Average Over Asking

$36k

Rhonda Mesenbourg

Coldwell Banker Cahoone

Average Over Asking

$100k

Average Days on Market

80

Single Family Home Transactions

13

Linda Sturm

Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage

Average Days on Market

140

Average Over Asking

$50k

Condo Transactions

22

Karen Taylor

RE/MAX Coast & Country

Average Days on Market

130

Fishers Island Listings Sold

1

Average Over Asking

$28k


I live in Atlanta and used HomeLight to find an agent to sell my late father's home in New York. The agent I chose went out of her way to ensure a sale. HomeLight saved me a lot of time and effort.

Michelle J.


I had never sold a house and didn't know any Realtors when I came across HomeLight. What blessing it was! I'm genuinely happy with the entire experience and would recommend HomeLight to anyone.

Ed S


I tell everyone about HomeLight. It's free! They connected me with agents who brought tons of useful info to our first meeting. The one I chose sold my home fast and for more than the asking price.

JM H.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the right time to hire a real estate agent in Fishers Island?

It's going to depend on the temperature of the Fishers Island housing market but we generally recommend that you hire a real estate agent as soon as you're thinking of selling your home. Generally speaking, that's anywhere from 3 to 6 months prior to your desired move date.

How important is it to hire a top real estate agent in Fishers Island?

On average, the top performing 5% of seller's agents generally command a higher selling price (+9%) than the average real estate agent. The top performing 5% of buyer's agents generally save their clients 2.5% more than the average real estate agent at closing. So, whether you're buying or selling your house, your odds of making more money on the transaction are higher if you work with a top performing agent.

Why do I need to hire a licensed real estate agent in Fishers Island?

Always ensure you’re working with a trained, accredited real estate professional. That's the best way to protect you and your property. Every listing agent should be prepared to deliver proof of their license to sell in your area.

What is the average real estate agent commission for agents in Fishers Island?

While individual real estate agent commissions do vary, most real estate agents in Fishers Island work for 6% of the home price.

How do I find a real estate agent that specializes in a specific Fishers Island neighborhood?

Looking to buy or sell a home in a specific Fishers Island neighborhood? We've got you covered. Either explore top real estate agents in Fishers Island neighborhoods or give one of our trained agent concierges a call at (888) 998-1909

What are the most important questions to ask when interviewing Fishers Island neighborhood?

We've put together a list of 24 questions to ask your real estate agent. Make sure to ask them of your Fishers Island real estate agent during interviews.

Why should I use HomeLight to find a Fishers Island real estate agent?

HomeLight analyzes all real estate agents in Fishers Island to bring you custom, unbiased, data-driven recommendations. We use actual home sales transaction data to compare Fishers Island real estate agents and will only introduce you to the top performing agents.

Do these Fishers Island real estate agents work for HomeLight?

No. All of the real estate agents you see on HomeLight.com are unaffiliated with us. They do not pay to advertise on our site and we do not pay to list them. That's how we keep our recommendations objective.

What factors does HomeLight consider when evaluating real estate agents in Fishers Island?

We compare real estate agents on a variety of data points in their transaction history. While we can't give away our exact algorithm, we can tell you that we consider things like: how fast a real estate agent sells, how many properties they work on, how much money they save or earn their clients, and what cities and neighborhoods they specialize in.