Updated regularlyAnalyzed 75 agents

Find the top real estate agents in Jay County, IN

We analyzed 75 Jay agents on closed volume, sale-to-list ratio, and review quality. Tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll match you with the best agent, suited for your exact needs.

Please enter a valid city and state.
Ex: San Francisco, CA
100% freeNo obligationBased on historical performance
How this works
75agents analyzed
Every licensed Jay agent — not a paid directory.
45M+transactions analyzed nationwide
Our algorithm scores every agent across dozens of variables — volume, sale-to-list, days on market, and more.
200,000+customer testimonials nationwide
Real feedback from real home sellers and buyers, cross-referenced with closed transactions.
100% Freeto you
No markup on commission. Agents pay us only if you close.

Featured in

Why it matters who you pick

Top Jay agents sell faster and for more — here’s the gap.

Data pulled from Jay listings closed in the last 12 months. The top 3% of agents consistently outperform the rest of the market on every seller metric.

Metric (last 12 months)
Top 3% of Jay
Average Jay agent
Top performers…
Sale-to-list ratio
99%
95%
+4 pts higher
Days on market
51
81
30 days faster
Homes sold per year
416
85
5× more deals

Based on Jay listings analyzed over the last 12 months.

Top Real Estate Agents & Realtors® in Jay County, IN

  1. Jeffrey CummingsRE/MAX Complete5.0/5 (7 reviews)
  2. Leander DeguiseYour Home Sold Guaranteed Realty5.0/5 (1 reviews)
  3. Kent ArnoldHeartland Auction & Realty, Inc.
  4. Kathy JohnsonProperty House Real Living
  5. Brock ReaganBerkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty
  6. Aaron LoyLoy Real Estate
  7. Scott LightfootERA Integrity Real Estate
  8. Steven PrybyllaRE/MAX Real Estate Groups
  9. Sherry AndersonRE/MAX Real Estate Groups
  10. Kami JohnsonKosciusko County Lakes Realty
  11. Sean BurchamColdwell Banker The Real Estate Group
  12. Mark CovaultF.C. Tucker Muncie, REALTORS
  13. Marilyn HuddlestonBerkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty
  14. Andrew WagnerWagner Auctioneering and Real Estate
  15. Kristen ReynoldsCentury 21 Advance Realty
  16. Troy ClouseClouse Realty Group, LLC
  17. Joni Donaghy-MyersColdwell Banker Holloway
  18. Erin PhillipsRE/MAX Real Estate Groups
  19. Jerrett FlesherWagner Auctioneering and Real Estate
  20. Samantha StonerNorth Eastern Group Realty
  21. Emily WilliamsTerrell Realty Group, LLC
  22. Sherri FinnertyJack Houck Real Estate
  23. Kelly WoodWood Realty Group
  24. Kathy SmithNextHome Elite Real Estate
  25. Matt GlentzerTarter Realty, Auction, & Appraisal
  26. Troy RobertsCentury 21 Advance
  27. Delmar W WaglerIntegrity Realty Group LLC
  28. Rodney RouchBerkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty
  29. Jairo CorreaRE/MAX Evolve
  30. Mark KellyBerkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty
  31. Melissa PuterbaughLoy Real Estate
  32. Ryan OrrRE/MAX Real Estate Groups
  33. Ryan KramerRemax Real Estate Groups
  34. Tina Cale-CoonsRE/MAX Real Estate Groups