5 Top Estate Sale Companies on Long Island
- Published on
- 7 min read
-
Alexandra Lee Associate EditorClose
Alexandra Lee Associate EditorAlexandra is an associate editor of HomeLight.com. Previously, she served as a writer and social media manager at Santa Barbara Life & Style Magazine, in addition to interning at the nonprofit honors society Phi Beta Kappa. Alexandra holds a bachelor's degree in communication and global studies from UC Santa Barbara, and she has three years of experience reporting on topics including international travel, luxury properties, celebrity interviews, fine dining, and more.
If you’re looking for estate sale companies on Long Island, you may be preparing to clear out a home filled with decades of personal belongings. Whether you’re handling an inherited estate, helping a loved one transition to a new living situation, or downsizing your own home, partnering with a reputable estate sale company can help ease an often complex and emotional process.
In this guide, we’ll highlight some of the top-rated estate sale companies on Long Island, outlining how they operate, what the process typically involves, what fees to expect, and how much you might expect to earn from a sale.
Sell Fast in Long Island With a Cash Offer or Top Agent
Get an all-cash, no-obligation offer on your Long Island home through HomeLight’s Simple Sale platform. Close in as few as 10 days with no repairs or showings. You can also request an expert estimate of what your home might sell for using a top Long Island agent.
Popular estate sale companies on Long Island
Here are five reputable estate sale companies serving the Long Island area:
Full of Surprizes Estate & Tag Sales
Full of Surprizes offers professional estate sales and online auctions across Long Island. Founder Madeline is a master’s degree-holding social worker with over 20 years of experience and leads the company to manage every step of the process — from appraisals and marketing to organization and cleanouts. Their sales often feature high-end items such as fine art, jewelry, antiques, and even cars, often selling through 99% of inventory. Full of Surprizes also leverages a thorough marketing strategy that includes a strong online presence and a newsletter reaching more than 14,000 subscribers.
- Website: fullofsurprizes.com
- Phone: 516-315-3102
- Better Business Bureau: Not rated
- Google customer reviews: 4.7 stars, based on 114 reviews
All Inclusive Estate Sales Inc.
Operating across New York, including Long Island, All Inclusive Estate Sales Inc. offers comprehensive estate liquidation services with an emphasis on high returns and minimal hassle. From exclusive in-person showings to nationwide online auctions, their four-phase process ensures every item is photographed, researched, marketed, and sold for top dollar. Known for efficient cleanouts and white-glove service, they aim to redefine industry standards and deliver optimal results for every client.
- Website: aiestatesales.com
- Phone: 877-335-2437
- Better Business Bureau: Not rated
- Google customer reviews: 4.9 stars, based on 144 reviews
Miss Spiffy Estate Sales
Miss Spiffy Estate Sales is a licensed, bonded, and insured company in New York, offering full-service estate sale management with a warm, personalized approach. Owned and operated by certified teachers Lisa and Jen, the business brings more than 14 years of experience and a compassionate mindset to each project. Whether you’re downsizing, relocating, or managing a loved one’s estate, Miss Spiffy handles everything from staging and organizing to promotion and sales, both online and in-person. They also offer optional clean-out services to help leave the home ready for its next chapter.
- Website: spiffyestatesales.com
- Phone: 347-454-1616
- Better Business Bureau: Not rated
- Google customer reviews: 4.7 stars, based on 47 reviews
All American Tag Sales
Based in Nassau County, NY, All American Tag Sales brings over 12 years of estate sale experience to clients across Long Island, the five boroughs, Westchester, and Southwest Connecticut. They offer in-person estate sales, online auctions, and consignments, customizing each service to meet clients’ unique needs. With no upfront or out-of-pocket fees, they provide transparent pricing and full-service support, including setup, staffing, security, and marketing to an audience of over 12,000+ subscribers.
- Website: allamericantagsales.com
- Phone: 516-521-8816
- Better Business Bureau: Not rated
- Google customer reviews: 4.3 stars, based on 29 reviews
Lots of Goodys Estate Tag Sale
Serving Brooklyn, Queens, Nassau, and Suffolk counties, Lots of Goodys brings over 15 years of family-run estate sale experience to every job. Known for their organization, security, and attention to detail, the company is insured up to $1 million and offers full-service sales with expert pricing, staging, and post-sale clean-out options. Each sale is staffed by seven employees and includes oversight by a certified gemologist at no charge. Their professional and compassionate approach ensures both high returns and peace of mind.
- Website: lotsofgoodys.com
- Phone: 516-316-9225
- Better Business Bureau: A+ rating, not accredited
- Google customer reviews: 4.9 stars, based on 107 reviews
Working with estate sale companies on Long Island
Professional estate sale companies on Long Island organize public sales to liquidate a significant portion of a home’s contents. These companies handle everything from pricing and staging to marketing and managing the sale itself, aiming to attract buyers and maximize profits. Some companies specialize in online-only sales, while others offer a blend of on-site and digital options.
Unlike a garage sale, estate sales typically involve selling a wide variety of household items, including furniture, antiques, collectibles, artwork, jewelry, and everyday goods. Most sales run for between one and three days, with many companies offering final-day discounts to help clear out any remaining inventory.
After the sale, many companies provide additional services to deal with unsold items, such as arranging donations, consignment, or disposal. The goal is to leave the home empty and ready for its next chapter.
Estate sale costs and estimated proceeds
Most estate sale companies on Long Island charge a commission based on the total sales amount, typically ranging from 35% to 50%. The actual rate can vary depending on the size and complexity of the sale and the value of the items being sold. For example, some higher-value estates may qualify for lower commission rates.
Your take-home pay will depend directly on the accepted commission rate. According to EstateSales.net, the average estate sale generates between $18,000 and $20,000 in gross revenue. With an average commission rate of 35%–40%, this translates to around $10,800 to $13,000 in net earnings.
Many Long Island estate sale companies require a minimum of $5,000 to $10,000 in expected gross revenue before agreeing to manage a sale, though some may be flexible for smaller estates.
»Learn more: Estate Sale Company FAQs
Find more estate sale companies on Long Island
While we’ve already shared a few reputable estate sale companies on Long Island, it’s advisable to continue researching until you find a company that aligns with your unique needs, timeline, and financial goals. Here are some helpful resources for finding and vetting additional estate sale companies:
- EstateSales.org and EstateSales.net
- BBB ratings and reviews
- Google Local Services Pro List and reviews
- The National Estate Sales Association
- The American Society of Estate Liquidators (search directory)
- Ask a top Long Island real estate agent
How Much Is Your Inherited Home Worth?
If you’re curious about how much your inherited property might be worth, get a preliminary estimate from HomeLight’s free Home Value Estimator.
Do you need to empty a house before selling it?
No, you don’t always need to clear out a house before selling it. In fact, some real estate agents recommend keeping certain furniture and decor for staging purposes. If the home is already vacant, your agent might recommend virtual staging instead.
If you’re aiming for a faster and more convenient sale, HomeLight’s Simple Sale platform connects sellers with reliable cash buyers who purchase homes in nearly any condition — including those still filled with belongings.
»Learn more: Skip repairs, clean-up, and showings with a no-obligation cash offer
Next step: Sell the home with a top Long Island agent
Once the estate sale is complete, the next step is usually to liquidate the property itself. Whether you’re ready to offload an inherited property, downsize, or start over in a new location, collaborating with a top Long Island real estate agent can help you achieve a faster sale and a better return.
Through HomeLight’s free Agent Match platform, you can connect with Long Island’s top-performing real estate agents based on real transaction data. According to our research, the top 5% of agents sell homes for up to 10% more than the average agent — which could mean walking away with thousands more in your pocket.
Header Image Source: (NewAfrica / Deposit Photos)
At HomeLight, our vision is a world where every real estate transaction is simple, certain, and satisfying. Therefore, we promote strict editorial integrity in each of our posts.