Updated regularlyAnalyzed 544 agents

Find the top real estate agents in Old Mystic, CT

We analyzed 544 Old Mystic agents on closed volume, sale-to-list ratio, and review quality. Tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll match you with the best agent, suited for your exact needs.

100% freeNo obligationBased on historical performance
How this works
544agents analyzed
Every licensed Old Mystic agent — not a paid directory.
45M+transactions analyzed nationwide
Our algorithm scores every agent across dozens of variables — volume, sale-to-list, days on market, and more.
200,000+customer testimonials nationwide
Real feedback from real home sellers and buyers, cross-referenced with closed transactions.
100% Freeto you
No markup on commission. Agents pay us only if you close.
MLS, public records, HomeLight database

Featured in

Why it matters who you pick

Top Old Mystic agents sell faster and for more — here’s the gap.

Data pulled from Old Mystic listings closed in the last 12 months. The top 3% of agents consistently outperform the rest of the market on every seller metric.

Metric (last 12 months)
Top 3% of Old Mystic
Average Old Mystic agent
Top performers…
Sale-to-list ratio
101.6%
94.7%
+6.9 pts higher
Days on market
69
113
44 days faster
Homes sold per year
392
81
4.8× more deals

Based on Old Mystic listings analyzed over the last 12 months.

Top Real Estate Agents & Realtors® in Old Mystic, CT

  1. David AurigemmaRegency Real Estate5.0/5 (3 reviews)
  2. Zoe Zrakas5.0/5 (1 reviews)
  3. Nathan Cholewa5.0/5 (1 reviews)
  4. Andy Schilke5.0/5 (1 reviews)
  5. Maria Turczanik1.0/5 (1 reviews)
  6. Jeremy St. LouisAssist 2 Sell/Stebbins Buyer & Sellers Realty
  7. Lisa Mireault
  8. Leo ChomenRandall s
  9. Ann Stewart
  10. Annmarie Fortier
  11. John Vincent
  12. Melissa Giangrasso
  13. Matt St. Amour
  14. Ivy Ong
  15. Katie Korpi
  16. Carol Parda-ziolko
  17. Emily Calkins
  18. Leslee Cook
  19. Ted O'brien
  20. Angela Hancock
  21. Amanda Boehm
  22. Carol CraigPrudential Connecticut Realty
  23. Scott Boyden
  24. Lewis Jump
  25. Dan BurgioWilliam Raveis Real Estate
  26. Jon ArrudaArruda Real Estate Associates
  27. Paula TurleyRE/MAX Realty Group
  28. Carol ChristiansenRE/MAX Realty Group
  29. Debra ThomasSchilke Realty LLC
  30. Ashley Bowne
  31. Renee SandovalMcBride Real Estate
  32. Joseph Malerbaexp realty

How Agent Match works

Meet three top Old Mystic listing agents in under 48 hours

We’ve done the vetting. You pick the fit. The entire service is free — we’re paid by agents only if you close a transaction.

1
Illustration of a home valuation form

Tell us about your home

Two minutes, five questions. Address, timeline, price tier. We auto-fill what we can from public records.

2
Illustration of agent matching results

We match you to 2–3 agents

We shortlist the top agents in your specific neighborhood and price tier — not the whole city list.

3
Illustration of a homeowner interviewing a real estate agent

You interview. Zero obligation.

Meet your matches, compare strategies, and pick the one who fits — or none at all. You're in control the whole way.

“HomeLight is a way to narrow the field and find the right agent for your house sale… Within 36 hours of listing, we had a contract.”

Frank L.

Sold with a HomeLight Agent

“I'd already met two agents on my own. HomeLight's match was better than both. Smooth from handoff through closing.”

James T.

Sold in 9 days

Old Mystic FAQ

Questions Old Mystic sellers actually ask.

Answered with live Old Mystic data. Updated monthly when the MLS refreshes.

The Old Mystic market is competitive, with well-priced homes typically selling within days of listing at or above asking price. Inventory remains below historical averages, which continues to favor sellers. Median prices have appreciated year-over-year, driven by strong demand and limited supply.
The national average real estate commission is typically between 5% and 6% of the home's final sale price. The exact rate is always negotiable. Post-2024 NAR settlement, buyer-side compensation is now separately negotiated between seller and buyer directly.
Spring (April–June) is historically the strongest window to list in Old Mystic. Homes listed in spring sell faster and closer to (or above) asking price. That said, low inventory year-round means motivated buyers exist in every season, so listing when your home is ready often beats waiting for the "perfect" month.
Prioritize agents with recent Old Mystic transaction history (25+ closings in the last 12 months), a strong sale-to-list ratio (102%+ is excellent), verifiable client reviews, and proven specialization in your neighborhood and price tier. Always interview 2–3 candidates before deciding.
Well-priced homes in desirable Old Mystic neighborhoods often accept offers within a week. From list date to close-of-escrow, plan on 30–45 days total, including buyer financing contingencies and inspections.
With prices appreciating and inventory tight in Old Mystic, conditions currently favor sellers. The primary reason to wait would be targeting the peak spring listing window — but holding several months carries the risk of rate or demand shifts that could reduce your net proceeds. In most cases, listing when your home is ready outperforms market timing.
HomeLight's Agent Match is 100% free for home sellers and buyers, with no obligation to work with the agents we recommend. We collect a referral fee from the agent only if you close a transaction with them — the service costs you nothing extra.
We analyze 45M+ transactions nationwide and score every licensed Old Mystic agent on recent transaction volume, sale-to-list ratio, days on market, client review quality, and neighborhood specialization. Only the top few percent of Old Mystic agents make our featured list, and we re-score monthly as new data arrives.
Absolutely — and we encourage it. HomeLight matches you with 2–3 top-performing Old Mystic agents tailored to your home's location, price tier, and timeline. There's no obligation to work with any of them, and our concierge team can help you prepare questions specific to your neighborhood.
We analyze your home's location, estimated price tier, and your stated timeline, then match you with 2–3 top agents. A HomeLight concierge follows up within minutes to review your matches and answer any questions. The whole process — from submit to first agent conversation — typically takes under an hour.

How we match agents

Out of 544 agents in Old Mystic, we find the 2–3 best to sell your home.

Most agent directories are paid listings. HomeLight is different — our algorithm ranks every licensed Old Mystic agent on objective transaction data.

45M+ transactions
We score every agent on every sale — recency, price band, and neighborhood — so your match reflects current performance, not old reputation.
Performance weighted
Sale-to-list ratio, days on market, and transaction volume — not star ratings or paid directory placement.
Client satisfaction
200,000+ verified reviews, cross-referenced against actual closed transactions to remove unverified feedback.
Hyperlocal fit
We match you with agents who have a proven track record in your specific neighborhood and price range — not just city-wide.

Agent rankings are updated regularly. Data sourced from MLS, public records, and HomeLight’s transaction database.

Explore nearby

Find top agents in Old Mystic neighborhoods & nearby cities

Old Mystic208 agents · avg $315K